With less than two weeks until the exam, I'm sure the lot of us are quite close to either suffering complete mental breakdowns or simply giving up on everything. Time will tell which outcome prevails.
In the previous weeks, we have done a large amount of test-preparation ranging from poetry analysis (BLITZKRIEG) to closed/open prompt essays to practice tests. While I definitely think one can never take enough practice tests, I think forcing ourselves to come up with theme statements for the poems we read during the Blitzkrieg was ultimately the most helpful activity; it improves our ability to formulate valid ideas within a limited period of time, which is really what the AP is all about.
We also finished Ceremony with few casualties; it was an extremely rich book with an extensive use of literary devices, which consequently will make it very useful when writing the essay portion of the exam.
The Weebly project was unlike anything I'd every experienced in an English class. At first I was slightly overwhelmed at the thought of writing on a topic that sounded like something a grad student would produce, but in the end I think it was an excellent exercise of our writing and analysis skills. Whereas papers in past classes often pose a question on a specific topic, allowing us to choose our own ensured that we genuinely had something to say on the subject, which I'm sure resulted in better writing. Had it been an individual assignment, however, I definitely think we all would have flipped. Having shared responsibility of the task lessened the pressure considerably and ensured that if one member hit a mental block, the others could help move past it. I'm rather proud of my group's work and I hope everyone else is as well.
As we finish up Fifth Business, continue some in-class practice, read our Princeton reviews, oil up our guns and head into battle, I'm confident that our experiences in this class have more than prepared us for reasonably painless AP exam experience.
Sunday, April 27, 2014
Sunday, April 20, 2014
I Heart Open Prompts
2009 A symbol is an object, action, or event that represents something or that creates a range of associations beyond itself. In literary works a symbol can express an idea, clarify meaning, or enlarge literal meaning. Select a novel or play and, focusing on one symbol, write an essay analyzing how that symbol functions in the work and what it reveals about the characters or themes of the work as a whole. Do not merely summarize the plot.
In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the tape recorder represents both an undeniable recount of the past that Willy simply cannot come to terms with and the ultimate end to Willy's career. Willy is highly caught up in his delusional perceptions of the past, and the tape recorder threatens these by its ability to replay exactly what has happened without bias.
Willy spends the majority of Death of a Salesman recalling more favorable memories in the face of his current, unhappy life. He remembers a time when his sons loved him unconditionally and often falls back into this period in his life in order to grapple with his current situation with Biff. Without these reveries, Willy would have had to come to terms with his failure as a father and a person with regard to his affair and thus the destruction of the relationship with his son. The tape recorder terrifies him because it doesn't lie, but rather relays things as they are, which is something Willy cannot do.
The recorder also represents the end of Willy's career; when he is attempting to change Howard's mind about his decision to fire Willy, Howard consistently ignores Willy's pleas in favor of discussion of his new recorder. A shift in honor of human to machine is quite present in Willy's time, and it's something he laments greatly. Though Howard is very much Willy's junior and has plenty of incentive to treat him with kindness, he does not because he is more focused on money and technology than the value of a man.
Willy's interaction with the recorder signifies an internal realization over his improper conceptions of life and thus the end of it. It indicates the beginning of the climax of the story, when Willy truly begins to lose his grip on reality and eventually falls apart inside and out.
In Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, the tape recorder represents both an undeniable recount of the past that Willy simply cannot come to terms with and the ultimate end to Willy's career. Willy is highly caught up in his delusional perceptions of the past, and the tape recorder threatens these by its ability to replay exactly what has happened without bias.
Willy spends the majority of Death of a Salesman recalling more favorable memories in the face of his current, unhappy life. He remembers a time when his sons loved him unconditionally and often falls back into this period in his life in order to grapple with his current situation with Biff. Without these reveries, Willy would have had to come to terms with his failure as a father and a person with regard to his affair and thus the destruction of the relationship with his son. The tape recorder terrifies him because it doesn't lie, but rather relays things as they are, which is something Willy cannot do.
The recorder also represents the end of Willy's career; when he is attempting to change Howard's mind about his decision to fire Willy, Howard consistently ignores Willy's pleas in favor of discussion of his new recorder. A shift in honor of human to machine is quite present in Willy's time, and it's something he laments greatly. Though Howard is very much Willy's junior and has plenty of incentive to treat him with kindness, he does not because he is more focused on money and technology than the value of a man.
Willy's interaction with the recorder signifies an internal realization over his improper conceptions of life and thus the end of it. It indicates the beginning of the climax of the story, when Willy truly begins to lose his grip on reality and eventually falls apart inside and out.
Thursday, April 17, 2014
Summary and Analysis- Ceremony by Leslie Marmon Silko
Important Facts:
The novel was published in 1977. It is set in post WWII on the Laguna-Pueblo reservation in New Mexico.
Silko is of mixed Laguna Pueblo, white, and Mexican descent.
The novel was published in 1977. It is set in post WWII on the Laguna-Pueblo reservation in New Mexico.
Silko is of mixed Laguna Pueblo, white, and Mexican descent.
The Theme Statement-
In Ceremony, Silko suggests that good and evil exist in everything and are therefore arbitrary classifications; understanding this allows one to achieve personal and communal balance and higher understanding of the natural order of the universe.
Characters:
Tayo- A WWII veteran of mixed Laguna and white ancestry, Tayo returns from the service plagued with a type of spiritual illness that Western culture would dub as PTSD. He is devastated over the loss of his cousin Rocky, whom Tayo grew up with after his mother left him with Auntie, or Rocky's mother. He is constantly vomiting, a reflection of his upset soul and the disquiet he feels with regard to the stories that live there. Ultimately, his mixed race allows him to surpass cultural boundaries and see that despite misconceptions held between the two regarding the other, Western and Native American culture can coexist peacefully, and neither is more or less correct than the other as good and bad exist in all things. Over the course of the novel, Tayo's healing ceremony is complete, and he is cured.
Auntie- Tayo's aunt who raised him after her sister abandoned him. She never took a liking to Tayo, a fact of which he was well aware. As a practicing Catholic, she rejects many aspects of Laguna culture in favor of Western ideals.
Josiah- Auntie's brother and Tayo's father figure, Josiah also embraces the tribe's values and Tayo is very close to him. He is responsible for purchasing the Mexican cattle that Tayo finds later in the story.
Rocky- Tayo's cousin who died at war, Rocky was much beloved by his community and embraced Western culture like his mother. Much of Tayo emotional distress arises from his death, as he cannot let go and move on from it.
Old Grandmother- Still believes in the traditional Laguna beliefs; thus, she is rather fond of Tayo, as he represents much of what their culture is beginning to lose to the Western world.
Ts'eh- Representing Corn Woman and other important female figures in Laguna culture, Ts'eh is one of two women that work to nurture Tayo during his ceremony. She is integral in Tayo's healing process, infusing him with nature and positive energy.
Emo- The ringleader of the witches, Emo represents the evil affects of Western culture with his drinking problem and reverence of the army. In conquering Emo's reverse-ceremony, Tayo finishes his own and ensures that good triumphs. (This time)
Betonie- The Laguna medicine man, Betonie helps Tayo with his ceremony. He understands that the rules of the ceremony can adjust as time wears on without losing their importance, possibly because like Tayo, he is also of mixed ancestry and is able to see past racial boundaries.
Important Plot Points:
- Tayo returns home from WWII where he fought in the Philippines and lost his beloved cousin Rocky in the Bataan Death March.
- He is stricken with a spiritual illness that manifests itself in the form of physical sickness and cannot seem to overcome his affliction.
- The Western doctors have declared his condition PTSD.
- Auntie takes care of Tayo presently, but nothing seems to help.
- Harley and Tayo go to the bar to drink with the others.
- Tayp deeply mourns the loss of Rocky and his uncle Josiah, which happened when he was at war.
- Old Grandmother enlists Old Man Ku'oosh to help Tayo recover. (Believes in traditional values).
- Tayo stabs Emo in the stomach (Where his stories are).
- Betonie advises Tayo on his story; as part of this, he is to find Josiah's cattle.
- While on this journey is nature, Tayo is joined by Ts'eh, who represents feminine power and nature and assists with his healing process.
- He encounters a mountain lion, an important figure in Laguna culture.
- Ts'eh must leave but gives him directions to finish the ceremony. People are after him, and he must complete his journey alone.
- When Emo is about to complete his anti-ceremony, Tayo stops it by not stabbing him with the screwdriver. Thus, light triumphs over dark. (This time)
- Tayo has several great realizations over the natural order of the universe, deciding that to place blame on any one factor of suffering is pointless, that things "have never been easy" and good and evil exist in all things and people. The stars have always known this.
- Tayo's ceremony is complete.
Motifs:
- Hybrids
- Ceremony
- Medicine
- Tradition versus adaptation
- Real versus artificial
- Conflicting values
- Witchery
- Dependence
- Healing
- Bellies/Stories
- Cycles
- Numbers
- Nature
- Direction
- Stereotypes
- Fertility
- Language
- Matriarchy
- Sex
- Power
- Spirit
Quotes-
"Emo had liked what they showed him: big mortar shells that blew tanks and big trucks to pieces; jagged steel flakes that exploded from the grenades; the way the flame thrower melted a rifle into a shapeless lump... He was one of them. The best. United States Army." (pg. 57)
This quote exemplifies Emo's connection with Western culture and the unnatural; he is drawn to violence and metal and modern arms, all of which are clearly not represented in his native culture. He considers the U.S Army "the best", a reflection of his identification and reverence of white society.
"They are trying to decide who you are." (pg. 216)
Spoken by Ts'eh to Tayo, this quote sums up a large theme of the novel. Being of mixed race, society is constantly trying to categorize Tayo and behavior as one culture's or another when really, he is capable of overcoming both and seeing them as one.
"At home the people would blame liquor, the Army, and the war, but the blame on the whites would never match the vehemence the people would keep in their own bellies, reserving the greatest bitterness and blame for themselves, for one of themselves they could not save." (pg. 235) and "... It has never been easy." (pg. 235)
At this point in the novel, Tayo is nearing the end of his ceremony and begins coming to a series of revelations about the world. He sees that neither Laguna nor Western culture is perfect, and that there exists darkness in all things as well as light. This also sums up a great deal of the struggle Tayo's people have faced. "It has never been easy," he realizes, meaning that it is the nature of the world to present hardships to its people, but this is simply a fact of the universe.
Sunday, March 16, 2014
Gotta Love Responses to Course Material
Right, let's get to it then.
In the past month or so, we finished our Ros and Guil discussions, which truthfully left me feeling rather incomplete. We came up with some solid conclusions as to what the play is/is not trying to say, but I remain unconvinced that I fully understand it. Thus, I truly believe that Stoppard wrote this play just to mess with his readers' minds. It is so soaked in meaning, yet this meaning appears to be entirely up to interpretation.
It's hard to put that into a theme statement, however. That was a very irritating task, to say the least.
The Postmodern reading we did certainly helped with comprehension, with its discussion of concepts like ambiguity, complexity, and the conflicting nature of language within Ros&Guil. At the end of the day, though, I feel as though I'll have to read the play several times before I can make qualified remarks about it.
Now that we've started reading out first book, Ceremony, 'tis an exciting time in the kingdom. We did some preliminary reading on the subject in class with the Silko essays and the Tayo's World presentation, which I'm sure will assist us greatly in our comprehension of the novel later on. I quite enjoy it thus far, especially the writing--however, I can't help but dread the day when annotating time comes round. I'm not sure I'm emotionally prepared to properly annotate an entire book. Thank God for therapy.
Our review of critical lenses has been rather helpful. Having taken both British and American Lit, I already had a considerable amount of prior knowledge on the subject, but the Powerpoint really solidified and expanded my understanding of the various lenses. Last year, I wrote a paper analyzing Clockwork Orange through an archetypal lens, but I feel like I'm far better informed on the subject now, and if I were to go back and redo it now it would likely sound far more sophisticated and, well, intelligent.
Having several days dedicated to freely analyzing all of the plays we read through lenses of our choice has been interesting, to say the least. My class stumbled our way around a sad discussion of The American Dream as interpreted through a feminist lens, and then moved on to psychoanalyzing the characters of Hamlet, which led to greater success. I think it's interesting that the various classes have such differing ideas about the plays; when we all come together to share them during that project thing Holmes vaguely mentioned to us, I'm sure our minds will be all types of blown.
As for actual classwork, we wrote a closed-prompt essay on Twelve, which really emphasized for me the fact that I really need to work on my time management skills. As painful as in-class essays are, I know that they are highly important for us to do if we want to score anything near a respectable score on the exam. Which is in less than two months. Let the anxiety dreams commence.
We also analyzed "Defending Walt Whitman", which apparently took my class about a day longer than it did for the others. This is mostly because we tend to get hung up on one aspect of our analyses and discuss it for too long rather than identifying several concepts and exploring them all lightly and equally. Again, for the time sensitive AP, this is something we must work on.
Oh, and then there was the mythoi discussion in class with the whole circular nature of seasons/romance/tragedy thing, which helped us understand the cycle of character journeys. Do see Max's blog for a visual representation of that in doughnut form.
In the past month or so, we finished our Ros and Guil discussions, which truthfully left me feeling rather incomplete. We came up with some solid conclusions as to what the play is/is not trying to say, but I remain unconvinced that I fully understand it. Thus, I truly believe that Stoppard wrote this play just to mess with his readers' minds. It is so soaked in meaning, yet this meaning appears to be entirely up to interpretation.
It's hard to put that into a theme statement, however. That was a very irritating task, to say the least.
The Postmodern reading we did certainly helped with comprehension, with its discussion of concepts like ambiguity, complexity, and the conflicting nature of language within Ros&Guil. At the end of the day, though, I feel as though I'll have to read the play several times before I can make qualified remarks about it.
Now that we've started reading out first book, Ceremony, 'tis an exciting time in the kingdom. We did some preliminary reading on the subject in class with the Silko essays and the Tayo's World presentation, which I'm sure will assist us greatly in our comprehension of the novel later on. I quite enjoy it thus far, especially the writing--however, I can't help but dread the day when annotating time comes round. I'm not sure I'm emotionally prepared to properly annotate an entire book. Thank God for therapy.
Our review of critical lenses has been rather helpful. Having taken both British and American Lit, I already had a considerable amount of prior knowledge on the subject, but the Powerpoint really solidified and expanded my understanding of the various lenses. Last year, I wrote a paper analyzing Clockwork Orange through an archetypal lens, but I feel like I'm far better informed on the subject now, and if I were to go back and redo it now it would likely sound far more sophisticated and, well, intelligent.
Having several days dedicated to freely analyzing all of the plays we read through lenses of our choice has been interesting, to say the least. My class stumbled our way around a sad discussion of The American Dream as interpreted through a feminist lens, and then moved on to psychoanalyzing the characters of Hamlet, which led to greater success. I think it's interesting that the various classes have such differing ideas about the plays; when we all come together to share them during that project thing Holmes vaguely mentioned to us, I'm sure our minds will be all types of blown.
As for actual classwork, we wrote a closed-prompt essay on Twelve, which really emphasized for me the fact that I really need to work on my time management skills. As painful as in-class essays are, I know that they are highly important for us to do if we want to score anything near a respectable score on the exam. Which is in less than two months. Let the anxiety dreams commence.
We also analyzed "Defending Walt Whitman", which apparently took my class about a day longer than it did for the others. This is mostly because we tend to get hung up on one aspect of our analyses and discuss it for too long rather than identifying several concepts and exploring them all lightly and equally. Again, for the time sensitive AP, this is something we must work on.
Oh, and then there was the mythoi discussion in class with the whole circular nature of seasons/romance/tragedy thing, which helped us understand the cycle of character journeys. Do see Max's blog for a visual representation of that in doughnut form.
Sunday, March 9, 2014
Open Prompt #3
In Kate Chopin’s The Awakening (1899), protagonist Edna
Pontellier is said to possess “That outward existence which conforms, the
inward life that questions.” In a novel or play that you have studied, identify
a character who outwardly conforms while questioning inwardly. Then write an essay in which you
analyze how this tension between outward conformity and inward questioning
contributes to the meaning of the work. Avoid mere plot summary.
In Edward Albee's The American Dream, Grandma acts outwardly as a senile old woman whom the characters readily dismiss, but inwardly she is rather sage and appears to know much more about the world than anyone else in the play. The dichotomy created here contributes to the meaning of the play as a whole by accurately mirroring society's problem of ignoring those possessing wisdom and respectable values in order to promote those of materialism and superficiality; because of this, in order to get anything done, Grandma must act differently than she feels.
Grandma's outward treatment of the boxes shows us that she can be successful in both fooling those around her into thinking that she is a normal member of their society while ensuring that her secret, inner values will be preserved as she takes them with her when she leaves. Her conforming to her family's view of her as a crazy old lady while clearly understanding more about her world than she lets on hints at the meaning of the work itself. When Grandma is ultimately shoved off to make room for the new American dream, the ultimate point of the play is exposed; those with contradictory values to that of the majority ultimately have no place in society.
At one point in the play, Grandma recounts the story of when she entered a baking competition with a store-bought cake and won the grand prize. Her knowledge that the store bought cake would win the competition--a direct reflection of society's upholding of materialist, disingenuous things--shows that she conforms outwardly to expectations set upon her, she knows full well the nature of those expectations and how to play them successfully. This contributes to the play's overall meaning in that it both exposes a societal flaw while highlighting Grandma's inner understanding of her surroundings and her ability to interact successfully with a world that she outwardly conforms to while inwardly sees through entirely.
When speaking to the Young Man, Grandma acts with precision, knowing full well that he would be her replacement in the family and orchestrating that this would be the case. She listens to his dark story involving his long lost twin, and all the while makes non-committal comments regarding his attractiveness and other meaningless features that would be the focus of any other character when interacting with him. At the end of their conversation, however, she whispers her plan into his ear and he obeys, thus ensuring that her vision of the future for her family is fulfilled. Grandma's expression of her society's emphasis on appearance and beauty and inner concoction of the perfect plan do well to show us the nature of her understanding of the difference between how she thinks and how she must act.
In The American Dream, Grandma understands that if she is to fit into the world around her, the way she acts outwardly must not reflect the thoughts she possesses inwardly. In this, she emphasizes the true meaning of the work; that those who understand the values of their societies, however flawed, and act accordingly regardless of their true feelings.
Thursday, March 6, 2014
Analyzing Ros & Guil While Sir T$topz the Puppetmaster Laughs From Above
THIS IS A PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT: DID YOU GUYS KNOW THAT TOM STOPPARD WAS KNIGHTED? MEANING HE'S ACTUALLY, LIKE, SIR TOM STOPPARD IRL? IS THAT NOT SICK?!
Theme
Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead warns that one's preoccupation with obtaining a sense of outside direction often prevents the development of a true individual identity.
Characters-
Rosencrantz- Acting as somewhat of a sidekick to Guildenstern, Rosencrantz is characterized by both his confusion and the distinct lack of qualms he has with his lack of understanding of the world. Quite the opposite of Guildenstern, Ros is in many ways his other half, representing the qualities that Guil does not have. He is quiet, simple, and significantly more accepting of his role in the universe than Guil. It becomes apparent through his many attempts to please him that Ros feels rather affectionate toward Guil. Where Guil is the tortured philosopher-scientist, Ros is more of happy simpleton, quite content with playing the same game over and over again and forgetting his 'lines', so to speak.
Guildenstern- Viewing the world with cynical, desperate eyes, Guil is constantly lamenting his lot in life and trying to gain an understanding of the world around. He acts as a bit of a babysitter to the significantly more passive Ros, whose behavior he often regards with frustration. Unable to fully reconcile with his place in the universe, which is admittedly a confusing one, he proposes an endless amount of questions that are not and cannot be readily answered, which increases his anger considerably. The important thing to remember about these two is that they are one in the same; one cannot exist without the other, and they are implied to be two halves of a whole person.
The Player- The puppet-master of the play (I really like the word puppet-master), the Player seems to know much more about the world Ros and Guil are a part of and often taunts them over it. He is not a character, but an actor, which is one step above their status in the universe, so to speak. The Player is also the leader of the Tradegians, a group of actors who put on the play within a play within a play. (The one in Hamlet that exposes Claudius as guilty)
Plot-
Act I-
- Beginning with Ros and Guil sitting on an empty stage, the two are shown flipping a coin which always lands as 'heads'. Guil is perplexed by this and attempts to justify it with half-baked, incorrect scientific theories while Ros doesn't question it.
- The Player comes in and rocks their world with his band of actors. Their conversation with the Player greatly confounds Ros and Guil, who struggle to understand his implications. The audience is discussed here as well, thus breaking the fourth wall.
- At the end of this act, Ros and Guil are thrust into Hamlet, where they act as his lifelong friends summoned by Claudius to glean a better understanding of his strange behavior; it is in their Hamlet scenes that the two remember their lines properly and seem to know their place.
Act II-
- Made up of clashes between down time for R&G, conversations with the Player, and appearances in Hamlet, the second act is a whirlwind of muddled events.
- When they are completely alone, Ros and Guil discuss profound topics such as death and religion but don't quite get anywhere. The Player continues to confuse them and their conversations suggest the dichotomy between actors and characters with regard to what "is written" and what is not.
- At the end of the act, the two get on the boat to England with Hamlet.
Act III-
- Boats as a symbol for life is emphasized in this act, and is is implied that Ros and Guil are headed to England/heaven, which may or may not be a conspiracy of cartographers. Here, the two debate the nature of life and death heavily, again not really getting anywhere with it.
- They uncover the letter ordering the death of Hamlet and are presented with the confusing pretense of their friendship with him. (He, of course, later switches the letter with the one ordering Ros and Guil's execution)
- Then, pirates. The boat is seized and the Player and Ros and Guil have a conversation about death, which does not truly exist for actors. The false letter is read and Ros and Guil disappear from the stage; the play is then closed in the same was as Hamlet, with Horatio's final lines.
Motifs-
Duality
Language
Confusion
Fate vs. Free Will
Homoeroticism
Art vs. Life
The Fourth Wall
The status of characters vs. actors vs. audience
Control
Direction
Entitlement
Repetition
Memory
Malapropisms
Search for-
Identity
Existential understanding
Direction
Comprehension of the tangible/intangible rules of the universe (Coin flipping/exploring the stage)
Quotes-
Rosencrantz- "Life in a box is better than no life at all." pg. 71
This quote is important for a variety of reasons. For one thing, it is spoken by Ros, ever the optimist. His suggestion that life, even meaningless, constrained life, is better than none at all is something that we can assume Guil may question, being that he spends the majority of his time searching for higher meaning. (We can assume that meaning would be difficult to pinpoint alone inside a box)
We must also ask ourselves what Ros means by "life in a box." In his examples he is discussing the situation literally, however the duality of language that dictates the play suggests that we could take it one step further and compare the hypothetical to life in general. Ros and Guil lead a restricted, simple life that confounds both of them. Judging by his statement, Ros is clearly more at ease with this than Guil.
Player- "We can't look each other in the face! You don't understand the humiliation of it--to be tricked out of the single assumption which makes our existence viable--that someone is watching..." pg. 63
Bringing religion and the nature of existence into the mix more than ever before, this quote backwardly introduces one of the most important concepts relevant to everyone's individual existence; is anyone watching?
Audience for 'real people' could very well be God; deciding whether or not one believes in a higher power is something everyone goes through and many struggle to fully understand.
Rosencrantz- Consistency is all I ask!
Guildenstern- (low, wry rhetori): Give us this our daily mask.
In their desperate attempt to reconcile with the world and better understand their place in it, Ros and Guil turn to outside forces to get answers. Through their misspoken prayers and crying out to oblivion, the characters' demand for direction is ironically directed toward the wrong place. They do not turn to themselves and create an identity to make their existence bearable (And, being characters, probably could not), but further prolong their suffering by asking questions with no answers.
Tuesday, February 18, 2014
Response to Course Material
*My sincerest apologies for the late post, Ms. Holmes. I was incapacitated by a mysterious illness on Sunday and Monday and didn't have the energy to watch Netflix, let alone complete homework efficiently. Do forgive me.*
Our past month as an AP family has been devoted to all things Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. We finished our in-class reading of the play, watched the film, and annotated a lecture on the subject that frankly made me want to throw myself upon a sword.
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern was everything I'd hoped it would be. Discussing the implications of its symbols and commentary on existence as a class in incredibly fun, yet also slightly confusing as it appears that coming to a resolute consensus on any of the questions pitched to us is next to impossible. I'm sure that with further time to discuss and consider pirates and boats on our own, however, we'll come to some earth-shattering conclusions.
Watching the film allowed us to with R&G in a completely different dimension that I think helped with our understanding immensely. The fact that it was directed by Stoppard himself allowed us to make accurate connections between the play and the film because, of course, both were created by the same person. As far as understanding which characters exist in the various realities present in the story, I think the visual representation allowed us to better understand what Stoppard was trying to convey to us as opposed to just reading it aloud in class.
Holmes, as we all know, is the puppet master. She owns all of our souls and can control how we think, thus giving her the ability to sway our minds one way or another depending on how she's feeling that day. This is apparent with our reading and annotating of the Stoppard lecture. My confusion grew as I delved farther and farther into the reading, and by the last page I had become infuriated with the author and every point he made in his useless 12 page analysis. To say that he was merely delighted by R&G, as if it were an adorable little production put on by his daughter's third grade class, and not moved in any way is borderline insulting. To everyone. How could the abundance of symbolism and references to the very nature of existence, (And in many ways, I thought, religion) not move someone?
It was then I realized that Holmes was challenging our thinking, daring us to disagree with the material put in front of us. Rarely have the majority of the classes I've taken asked us to engage with rather than simply absorb any required reading, so I found it refreshing that Holmes didn't give us this lecture and tell us to memorize its points, but rather consider it and compare its ideas with our own. Reason #237 Why I love this class.
Aside from all of the R&G, we also did some much-needed practice with open prompts and intros to our essays. Though I think many of us felt terrified and under-prepared when faced with the idea of writing our own questions and constructing coherent intro paragraphs in a limited amount of time, I think it was an exercise we all benefited from in the long run. Surely by the time May rolls around and we're all in a constant state of panic over our upcoming exam, the prospect of timed essay writing will seem slightly less scary. Or at least we will all be significantly better prepared to take on the task.
Our past month as an AP family has been devoted to all things Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. We finished our in-class reading of the play, watched the film, and annotated a lecture on the subject that frankly made me want to throw myself upon a sword.
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern was everything I'd hoped it would be. Discussing the implications of its symbols and commentary on existence as a class in incredibly fun, yet also slightly confusing as it appears that coming to a resolute consensus on any of the questions pitched to us is next to impossible. I'm sure that with further time to discuss and consider pirates and boats on our own, however, we'll come to some earth-shattering conclusions.
Watching the film allowed us to with R&G in a completely different dimension that I think helped with our understanding immensely. The fact that it was directed by Stoppard himself allowed us to make accurate connections between the play and the film because, of course, both were created by the same person. As far as understanding which characters exist in the various realities present in the story, I think the visual representation allowed us to better understand what Stoppard was trying to convey to us as opposed to just reading it aloud in class.
Holmes, as we all know, is the puppet master. She owns all of our souls and can control how we think, thus giving her the ability to sway our minds one way or another depending on how she's feeling that day. This is apparent with our reading and annotating of the Stoppard lecture. My confusion grew as I delved farther and farther into the reading, and by the last page I had become infuriated with the author and every point he made in his useless 12 page analysis. To say that he was merely delighted by R&G, as if it were an adorable little production put on by his daughter's third grade class, and not moved in any way is borderline insulting. To everyone. How could the abundance of symbolism and references to the very nature of existence, (And in many ways, I thought, religion) not move someone?
It was then I realized that Holmes was challenging our thinking, daring us to disagree with the material put in front of us. Rarely have the majority of the classes I've taken asked us to engage with rather than simply absorb any required reading, so I found it refreshing that Holmes didn't give us this lecture and tell us to memorize its points, but rather consider it and compare its ideas with our own. Reason #237 Why I love this class.
Aside from all of the R&G, we also did some much-needed practice with open prompts and intros to our essays. Though I think many of us felt terrified and under-prepared when faced with the idea of writing our own questions and constructing coherent intro paragraphs in a limited amount of time, I think it was an exercise we all benefited from in the long run. Surely by the time May rolls around and we're all in a constant state of panic over our upcoming exam, the prospect of timed essay writing will seem slightly less scary. Or at least we will all be significantly better prepared to take on the task.
Sunday, February 9, 2014
A Second Attempt at an Open Prompt Essay
Prompt: Comment on the function of a foil in a piece of literature of your choice.
In literature, foils are typically characters secondary to the main character that serve to highlight his or her strengths and weaknesses. Shakespeare is well known for his use of foils, especially in Hamlet. In this particular play, several foils--specifically, Hamlet and Laertes, Ophelia and Gertrude, and Hamlet and Claudius--arise whose opposite actions and personas help us understand different characters at a deeper level.
When the ghost of Hamlet's father requests that Hamlet avenge his murder at the beginning of the play, the remainder of the story revolves around Hamlet's tortured deliberation as to whether or not he should obey his father and murder his uncle; in fact, this indecision is a defining characteristic of Hamlet's. When Laertes learns of his father's murder by Hamlet's hand, in contrast, he immediately returns to Elsinore, desperate to seek revenge on the man who killed his father. The enduring loyalty and decisiveness displayed by Laertes when he is put into more or less the exact same situation as Hamlet emphasizes the fact that Hamlet himself completely lacks these qualities.
As the only two female characters in Hamlet, Ophelia and Gertrude's characters are quite opposite to each other. Often referred to as the "virgin-whore" complex, the two's personalities represent the two prevailing notions of female behavior in Shakespeare's time. While Ophelia is loyal to her father and fairly innocent in demeanor, Gertrude's quick remarriage to her late-husband's brother implies her to be more of a sexual deviant, behavior that is condemned by Hamlet throughout the play. In many ways, the opposite characteristics of these two women serve to sum up Elizabethan England's various perceptions of women.
Hamlet and Claudius are defined in many ways by the qualities that one possesses that the other does not. For example, Hamlet's value of loyalty and morality contrast sharply to Claudius disregard of natural law, which he displays in the murder of his own brother. While Claudius is rather skilled at maintaining his composure when necessary, Hamlet is subject to breaking under pressure and allowing his true feelings to come to the surface, as is clear through the debate of his madness throughout the play. Though neither character is truly morally superior in any way, the differences in values between the two are important to consider when profiling the two men.
In literature, foils are typically characters secondary to the main character that serve to highlight his or her strengths and weaknesses. Shakespeare is well known for his use of foils, especially in Hamlet. In this particular play, several foils--specifically, Hamlet and Laertes, Ophelia and Gertrude, and Hamlet and Claudius--arise whose opposite actions and personas help us understand different characters at a deeper level.
When the ghost of Hamlet's father requests that Hamlet avenge his murder at the beginning of the play, the remainder of the story revolves around Hamlet's tortured deliberation as to whether or not he should obey his father and murder his uncle; in fact, this indecision is a defining characteristic of Hamlet's. When Laertes learns of his father's murder by Hamlet's hand, in contrast, he immediately returns to Elsinore, desperate to seek revenge on the man who killed his father. The enduring loyalty and decisiveness displayed by Laertes when he is put into more or less the exact same situation as Hamlet emphasizes the fact that Hamlet himself completely lacks these qualities.
As the only two female characters in Hamlet, Ophelia and Gertrude's characters are quite opposite to each other. Often referred to as the "virgin-whore" complex, the two's personalities represent the two prevailing notions of female behavior in Shakespeare's time. While Ophelia is loyal to her father and fairly innocent in demeanor, Gertrude's quick remarriage to her late-husband's brother implies her to be more of a sexual deviant, behavior that is condemned by Hamlet throughout the play. In many ways, the opposite characteristics of these two women serve to sum up Elizabethan England's various perceptions of women.
Hamlet and Claudius are defined in many ways by the qualities that one possesses that the other does not. For example, Hamlet's value of loyalty and morality contrast sharply to Claudius disregard of natural law, which he displays in the murder of his own brother. While Claudius is rather skilled at maintaining his composure when necessary, Hamlet is subject to breaking under pressure and allowing his true feelings to come to the surface, as is clear through the debate of his madness throughout the play. Though neither character is truly morally superior in any way, the differences in values between the two are important to consider when profiling the two men.
Thursday, January 30, 2014
Summary and Analysis of Hamlet
The Attempted Theme
Author- William Shakespeare. His son’s name was Hamnet. Hamlet was written right after Hamnet died as a boy. Also, Shakespeare’s father died close to the time the play was being written. Scholars speculate that these deaths strongly influenced the play.
Shakespeare’s Hamlet cautions that self doubt paired with moral corruption can lead to the subversion of providence.
From the Review-
Setting- Denmark, specifically the court of Elsinore. (Most of the time) in the 13th century.
Characters-
Hamlet- Main character in the play, ~30. Son of Old Hamlet and Gertrude, nephew to Claudius, who has just wed Gertrude. He finds the status quo at Elsinore unacceptable in its suppression of his true character. We presume that when he is in Elsinore, he loses the personality he had when he was at school in Wittenberg. Hamlet is in a “relationship” with Ophelia, which may result in a possible pregnancy and subsequent suicide. May have an Oedipal relationship with Gertrude. Kills Polonius, sentences Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to death in his place in England, kills Laertes with Laertes’ own poisoned sword, kills Claudius. Constantly contemplates suicide, and is perhaps having an existential crisis to do with his lack of character at Elsinore.
Gertrude- Hamlet’s mother, previously married to Old Hamlet, currently married to Claudius. It is strongly suggested that she is guilty of incest. (Not only with her brother-in-law/ husband, but also through an Oedipal relationship with Hamlet.) Queen and “Imperial Jointress of Denmark.” Dies after drinking the poisoned cup meant for Hamlet.
Claudius- King of Denmark, as elected by the council of Denmark’s elders. Hamlet’s father and uncle. Killed Hamlet’s father for the crown and Gertrude, and plots to kill Hamlet. Killed by Hamlet.
Ophelia- Daughter of Polonius, sister to Laertes. In a relationship with Hamlet, unbeknownst to most of the court. Possibly pregnant, goes insane after her father’s death and subsequently kills herself. Has a questionably close relationship with her brother, Laertes.
Laertes- Son of Polonius, brother of Ophelia. Spends most of the play in France, until Polonius is killed. After his father is slain by Hamlet, Laertes seeks vengeance on him and subsequently enters into a plot with Claudius to poison Hamlet in a duel. He is unaware of Ophelia’s lack of innocence. Kills Hamlet.
Polonius- Chief counselor to the King. Laertes’ and Ophelia’s father. Likes to work behind the scenes. Has two personalities, one for politics and one for his family. Killed by Hamlet by accident while he was hiding behind a tapestry in Gertrude’s closet, spying on their conversation for Claudius.
Key Events/Plot Summary-
Act 1
Scene 1
Horatio is told that the Ghost of the old king of Denmark, Hamlet, has been seen
Horatio sees the Ghost and attempts to talk to it, but it does not answer Horatio.
King Hamlet led a conquest against old Fortinbras
Scene 2
Claudius is introduced and makes a speech about his marriage and how young Fortinbras demands the lands taken by King Hamlet. Claudius sends ambassadors to stop an attack.
Laertes is given leave to go to France, with permission of Polonius.
Hamlet is introduced and is mourning his father, Claudius and Gertrude tell him to get over his father’s death.
Hamlet is not given permission to leave and go back to Wittenberg.
Hamlet is forced to stay in Denmark. He is upset about his mother’s marriage to his uncle. (Took place “within a month”)
Horatio and friends tell Hamlet about the Ghost and he agrees to join them.
Scene 3/4/5
Laertes (leaving for France) warns Ophelia not to fall for Hamlet and not to trust him.
Polonius says the same thing and orders her not to see Hamlet.
Hamlet, Horatio, and Marcellus are visited by the Ghost.
The Ghost wants to only speak to Hamlet.
The Ghost tells Hamlet that he was murdered by Claudius. The Ghost tells Hamlet to avenge his murder.
Hamlet makes his friends swear to secrecy.
Act 2
Scene 1
Polonius does not trust Laertes in France and sends someone there.
Ophelia was visited by Hamlet, who seemed crazy.
Polonius thinks that Hamlet is crazy because Ophelia will not see him.
Scene 2
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are sent to spy on Hamlet by Gertrude and Claudius.
Polonius tells Claudius that Hamlet is crazy with love for Ophelia. They go to spy on Hamlet.
Hamlet knows that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are spying for Claudius.
Hamlet decides to prove his uncle’s guilt by staging a play, The Murder of Gonzago.
Act 3
Scene 1-To Be or Not To Be
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern cannot find why Hamlet is mad.
Polonius makes Ophelia to find out about Hamlet’s madness and goes to spy with Claudius.
Hamlet sees Ophelia and is nice, but then he changes his attitude.
Hamlet says he never loved her.
After Hamlet leaves Claudius does not think that love is the cause of his madness. He decides to send Hamlet to England.
Polonius says not to and wait until Gertrude talks to him.
Scene 2
The play occurs. Hamlet and Horatio watch for a reaction from Claudius.
The Player King is killed by having poison poured in his ear.
Claudius gets upset and leaves.
Hamlet is asked to go see Gertrude.
Scene 3
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are ordered to take Hamlet to England.
Polonius plans to spy on Hamlet and Gertrude.
Claudius starts to pray and Hamlet wants to kill him there, but cannot because then Claudius would go to Heaven.
Scene 4
Polonius hides behind a tapestry in Gertrude’s room.
Hamlet enters and scares Gertrude, who calls for help. Polonius then calls for help.
Hamlet, thinking that Polonius is Claudius, stabs the tapestry.
Hamlet is then upset at Gertrude for marrying Claudius, when the Ghost appears and he is the only one to see. Gertrude thinks he is mad.
The Ghost reminds Hamlet to avenge King Hamlet’s death.
Act 4
Gertrude tells Claudius that Polonius is dead. Claudius sends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to find Hamlet, and the body.
Hamlet does not say where he put the body.
Claudius orders Hamlet to leave immediately for England. Claudius tells the audience he plans to have Hamlet killed in England.
Hamlet sees Fortinbras and his army.
Act 5
Scene 1
Two clowns (gravediggers) dig up poor Yorick’s bones to make room for Ophelia.
Scene 2
Hamlet has his “fall of the sparrow” speech.
He then duels with Laertes, is mortally wounded, kills Claudius, then relinquishes his control to Fortinbras
Motifs-
Ambiguity
Insularity
Incest
Identity
Providence
Revenge
Control
Religion
Duality (Natural vs. Unnatural, identity vs. public appearance, father & son, light vs. day, pure vs. impure)
Death
Surveillance
Misogyny
Ears & hearing
Synecdoche
Fortune/luck
Lack of trust
Mystery of death- afterlife
Nation as a poisoned body
Putting on persons- inner vs. outer self
Lies
Groups of 3
Madness
Quotes-
There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,
Than are dreamt of in your philosophy.
- Hamlet Act 1 Scene V
This quote first introduces the concept of "higher power" in the play. Hamlet is commenting on the mysterious nature of God and fate and the idea that humans cannot tamper with either.
Not a whit. We defy
augury. There’s a special providence in the fall of a sparrow. If it be now,
’tis not to come. If it be not to come, it will be now. If it be not now, yet
it will come—the readiness is all. Since no man of aught he leaves knows, what
is ’t to leave betimes? Let be.
- Hamlet Act 5 Scene II
At this point in the play, Hamlet give up on trying to defy his fate and allows God to resume control of his life. In this, events finally begin happening in Hamlet's favor.
Sunday, January 19, 2014
A Very Short Response to Course Material
A lot of things happened in the past 7 days of class.
Just kidding. Our time was cut short by snow days, early release days, and an excessive amount of FLEXs, but a good time was had by all regardless.
We finished our Hamlet discussions, a bittersweet conclusion to a glorious era in my studies of English literature. Our analysis was quite intensive, much more so than anything I've experienced in any other English class. Ms. Holmes' contributions to the conversation helped keep things interesting and ensured that we broke free from cyclical discussion whenever it befell us. I truly feel like I have a better understanding of this particular Shakespearean play than any of the others I've read in school. While Macbeth quickly became one of my favorites when we read it in British Lit last year, we certainly did not go as in-depth with our study of it, and after Hamlet, a large part of me wishes we had.
I really could have continued discussing the play for ages--there's so much to question and so many themes to debate, but alas, sluttish time, she screws us all. (Cred to Sonnet 55/The Fault in Our Stars for that joke) We had to move on to bigger and better things: finals.
While I personally would have enjoyed a project-based final, our collaborative exam review is probably the most beautiful thing ever to rock my academic world. I love the teamwork; I think it brings us all closer as an AP family. This is more useful than any study guide I've ever been given in my high school career, and we all had a hand in making it. Glorious, really.
I'm confident that by having this along with the term review games in our studying arsenal, we'll all ace this final. (Can't say the same about myself and pre-calc, though.)
Just kidding. Our time was cut short by snow days, early release days, and an excessive amount of FLEXs, but a good time was had by all regardless.
We finished our Hamlet discussions, a bittersweet conclusion to a glorious era in my studies of English literature. Our analysis was quite intensive, much more so than anything I've experienced in any other English class. Ms. Holmes' contributions to the conversation helped keep things interesting and ensured that we broke free from cyclical discussion whenever it befell us. I truly feel like I have a better understanding of this particular Shakespearean play than any of the others I've read in school. While Macbeth quickly became one of my favorites when we read it in British Lit last year, we certainly did not go as in-depth with our study of it, and after Hamlet, a large part of me wishes we had.
I really could have continued discussing the play for ages--there's so much to question and so many themes to debate, but alas, sluttish time, she screws us all. (Cred to Sonnet 55/The Fault in Our Stars for that joke) We had to move on to bigger and better things: finals.
While I personally would have enjoyed a project-based final, our collaborative exam review is probably the most beautiful thing ever to rock my academic world. I love the teamwork; I think it brings us all closer as an AP family. This is more useful than any study guide I've ever been given in my high school career, and we all had a hand in making it. Glorious, really.
I'm confident that by having this along with the term review games in our studying arsenal, we'll all ace this final. (Can't say the same about myself and pre-calc, though.)
Sunday, January 12, 2014
Open Prompts Pt.II
Tragic Figures as Instruments for the Suffering of Others
In Arthur Miller's mid-20th century play Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman serves as a classic example of the tragic figure in literature. Through his relationship with himself, his family, and with the rest of society, Willy's suffering directly exemplifies that of those he is connected to.
Willy lived a unglamorous life; he worked the majority of the time, produced two dysfunctional children, and in his old age scarcely had enough money to keep his family afloat. Because of this, toward the end of his life he constantly grappled with the thought of suicide, seeing the option as not only as a way out of his predicament but as a way to save his family-- the insurance money collected upon his death would be plenty to keep them living comfortably. Ultimately for these reasons, Willy does commit suicide, hoping that in its aftermath his beloved youngest son Biff will finally start a business and make something of his life; but this is not the case. Willy dies in vain because none of the things he hoped for his family in death actually occur. In this, we see true tragedy, a misguided martyr giving up his life for those who do not truly deserve it.
The Loman family is one of resentment and useless hope that in the end ensures that no two people have a healthy relationship. Willy is completely in love with his son Biff and believes that he is truly capable of greatness, but Biff does not at all share this opinion of himself. Upon catching his father having an affair with a woman when he was just out of high school, Biff loses all respect for Willy and from that point on in life stops seeing himself as worth just about anything. Willy's other son, Happy, is useless in the true sense of the word; he has little real ambition and looks at life with an empty contentment. He is certainly not full of outward and inwardly directed rage like his brother, but his life is just as much of a waste. These broken relationships, born much out of Willy's halfhearted presence in life and thus in the raising of his children are examples of how Willy's actions in life led to the suffering of those he loved most; the tragedy is found in that no matter how hard he tried, he could not fix his sons or make their lives better for them.
The life of struggle Willy led with his insufficient job and low quality of happiness derived from his life in general stands to represent what many fear in life and what much of society is plagued with; sometimes working hard isn't enough, and people are stuck working miserable jobs that hardly pay enough to keep them alive and well. The people Willy expects to help him out offer no assistance, and he rejects it from those who do because he is too busy being unable to comprehend why people he had faith in consistently let him down. In many ways, the story of Death of a Salesman is one of the small but profound fears the majority of society fears for itself; disintegration of family ties, financial instability, and loss of happiness. Willy's suffering represents that of many others, and his tragic life is full of parts that many can relate to.
Willy Loman is a true tragic figure; his life is one of despair and sadness, and he leaves behind a legacy of nothing more than a broken family and some insurance money, despite all of the high hopes of being remembered as a well loved man who did good things in his life. In his downfall, we see elements of suffering that characterize many parts of humanity and a story of a family that could certainly exist in the real world.
In Arthur Miller's mid-20th century play Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman serves as a classic example of the tragic figure in literature. Through his relationship with himself, his family, and with the rest of society, Willy's suffering directly exemplifies that of those he is connected to.
Willy lived a unglamorous life; he worked the majority of the time, produced two dysfunctional children, and in his old age scarcely had enough money to keep his family afloat. Because of this, toward the end of his life he constantly grappled with the thought of suicide, seeing the option as not only as a way out of his predicament but as a way to save his family-- the insurance money collected upon his death would be plenty to keep them living comfortably. Ultimately for these reasons, Willy does commit suicide, hoping that in its aftermath his beloved youngest son Biff will finally start a business and make something of his life; but this is not the case. Willy dies in vain because none of the things he hoped for his family in death actually occur. In this, we see true tragedy, a misguided martyr giving up his life for those who do not truly deserve it.
The Loman family is one of resentment and useless hope that in the end ensures that no two people have a healthy relationship. Willy is completely in love with his son Biff and believes that he is truly capable of greatness, but Biff does not at all share this opinion of himself. Upon catching his father having an affair with a woman when he was just out of high school, Biff loses all respect for Willy and from that point on in life stops seeing himself as worth just about anything. Willy's other son, Happy, is useless in the true sense of the word; he has little real ambition and looks at life with an empty contentment. He is certainly not full of outward and inwardly directed rage like his brother, but his life is just as much of a waste. These broken relationships, born much out of Willy's halfhearted presence in life and thus in the raising of his children are examples of how Willy's actions in life led to the suffering of those he loved most; the tragedy is found in that no matter how hard he tried, he could not fix his sons or make their lives better for them.
The life of struggle Willy led with his insufficient job and low quality of happiness derived from his life in general stands to represent what many fear in life and what much of society is plagued with; sometimes working hard isn't enough, and people are stuck working miserable jobs that hardly pay enough to keep them alive and well. The people Willy expects to help him out offer no assistance, and he rejects it from those who do because he is too busy being unable to comprehend why people he had faith in consistently let him down. In many ways, the story of Death of a Salesman is one of the small but profound fears the majority of society fears for itself; disintegration of family ties, financial instability, and loss of happiness. Willy's suffering represents that of many others, and his tragic life is full of parts that many can relate to.
Willy Loman is a true tragic figure; his life is one of despair and sadness, and he leaves behind a legacy of nothing more than a broken family and some insurance money, despite all of the high hopes of being remembered as a well loved man who did good things in his life. In his downfall, we see elements of suffering that characterize many parts of humanity and a story of a family that could certainly exist in the real world.
Thursday, January 2, 2014
Response to Course Material: Hamlet on Screen
*So, uh, as an effect of my African truancy stunt, I was only here for two weeks of school in December and therefore I'm sure I missed quite a few important things necessary for this blog post. I also haven't had Internet for the past week or so- an absolutely horrifying experience, wouldn't recommend it- which is why this is late*
I was present for three of the five Hamlet films we watched in class: Olivier's, Jacobi's, and Hawke's. It's a shame I missed the others, I'm sure they were glorious. It was interesting to see the various adaptations of Hamlet from the stage to the screen and, more specifically, what directors chose to emphasize with regard to the important plot elements of the play.
Olivier's interpretation was extremely well done. It held the alluring quality that most black and white films tend to have, which worked well in playing up the darker elements of the play. Hamlet was appropriately aged in what appeared to be his mid-thirties, which made the whole Oedipus complex thing with his not-too-much-older mother slightly more believable/disturbing. The directing style was also full of symbolism, portraying Elsinore as a lonely, secluded place on a cliff, teetering both literally and figuratively on the edge of destruction. The eerie shots of the castle's stairways and corridors added added a flare of mystery, coming together in the end with Hamlet's somber funeral march up the mountain, a fairly obvious allusion to his ascent to heaven.
Hawke's rip-off of Baz Luhrman's directing style in Romeo and Juliet was insulting to say the least, and the film itself just didn't do much for me. The corporate setting was original, I suppose, but just didn't fit the plot too well for my tastes. I did however enjoy the way Ophelia and Hamlet's relationship was portrayed. It came off as much more accessible, and as an audience we could relate to the scenes that displayed their struggles and conflicting emotions much better than compared to the other films. The scenes with the ghost could have been better, I think; they were a bit understated, but then again so were many other parts of the film.
Also, Ethan Hawke just irks me in general, so that probably adds to my discontent with the production itself.
Jacobi's version was forgettable; the set was wrong, the acting was unimpressive, and it was simply a play being filmed rather than a new interpretation of a classic story. We also watched Shakespeare Uncovered, which was told to us by a Scottish man with a funny little accent/haircut. It exposed some rather interesting facts, such as the name of Shakespeare's lost son and how that may have influenced his writing of the play.
I thoroughly enjoyed annotating "Tragic Balance in Hamlet"; I found the essay intriguing and exceedingly informative, as it referenced so many other Shakespearean scholars and their interpretations on various themes of the play. It really opened my eyes and helped me with my annotations, which I was still working on at the time.
I was present for three of the five Hamlet films we watched in class: Olivier's, Jacobi's, and Hawke's. It's a shame I missed the others, I'm sure they were glorious. It was interesting to see the various adaptations of Hamlet from the stage to the screen and, more specifically, what directors chose to emphasize with regard to the important plot elements of the play.
Olivier's interpretation was extremely well done. It held the alluring quality that most black and white films tend to have, which worked well in playing up the darker elements of the play. Hamlet was appropriately aged in what appeared to be his mid-thirties, which made the whole Oedipus complex thing with his not-too-much-older mother slightly more believable/disturbing. The directing style was also full of symbolism, portraying Elsinore as a lonely, secluded place on a cliff, teetering both literally and figuratively on the edge of destruction. The eerie shots of the castle's stairways and corridors added added a flare of mystery, coming together in the end with Hamlet's somber funeral march up the mountain, a fairly obvious allusion to his ascent to heaven.
Hawke's rip-off of Baz Luhrman's directing style in Romeo and Juliet was insulting to say the least, and the film itself just didn't do much for me. The corporate setting was original, I suppose, but just didn't fit the plot too well for my tastes. I did however enjoy the way Ophelia and Hamlet's relationship was portrayed. It came off as much more accessible, and as an audience we could relate to the scenes that displayed their struggles and conflicting emotions much better than compared to the other films. The scenes with the ghost could have been better, I think; they were a bit understated, but then again so were many other parts of the film.
Also, Ethan Hawke just irks me in general, so that probably adds to my discontent with the production itself.
Jacobi's version was forgettable; the set was wrong, the acting was unimpressive, and it was simply a play being filmed rather than a new interpretation of a classic story. We also watched Shakespeare Uncovered, which was told to us by a Scottish man with a funny little accent/haircut. It exposed some rather interesting facts, such as the name of Shakespeare's lost son and how that may have influenced his writing of the play.
I thoroughly enjoyed annotating "Tragic Balance in Hamlet"; I found the essay intriguing and exceedingly informative, as it referenced so many other Shakespearean scholars and their interpretations on various themes of the play. It really opened my eyes and helped me with my annotations, which I was still working on at the time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)