Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt Response 3

Prompt:  Comment on the function of a foil in a piece of literature of your choice.

Essay #1- As has become typical for me upon reading these first essays, I found the student’s description of the foils present in Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club to be lackluster at best. The language did not flow very well, and the syntax of the overall piece was stiff. It appeared to me that rather than focus on the specific character traits that supported his or her claim that the two characters at hand were indeed foils, the author instead more or less gave an entire synopsis of the novel in a three-page essay. This essay of course got an 8, though, so the graders had to have seen something of value in the writer’s tactic. I would say that perhaps the large amount of textual evidence, sufficient foil-like connections between the two characters, and author’s prudent series of restatements of the prompt throughout the essay all contributed to it not being truly terrible. Personally, I would give it more of a 6 for lack of clarity and truly well-developed ideas, but alas, I am not a well-trained AP grader, so my opinion is not a valid one.

Essay #2- Not entirely developed and lacking in coherent structure, this student’s essay knew what it wanted to say, just not quite how to say it. Full of grammar errors and fragmented sentences, the flow of the essay was off, making it difficult to decipher who exactly the student thought Celie’s foil to be: her father or ‘Shug.’ While there was much textual evidence present to support the claims the author made, it simply made too many. This lack of coherency lead to a less valuable essay overall and is what I would think led to its lower score of a 6. Though the author surely knew the meaning of a foil—it even introduced the concept of Maslow’s hierarchy—the details it provided in attempt to support its claims about the character’s path to self-actualization were too spread-out and did not make obvious statements as to which character served as Celie’s foil. It seemed in the beginning that Celie’s father was her foil, and in the middle it appeared that it was instead Shug that taught Celie her important values. But in the end, the author restated that it was indeed her father, a thought process very confusing to the reader.

Essay #3- Beginning with an intro that could have come from a mind with the scholarly intellect of a six year old, the third essay was unpromising from the start. It neglected to produce a well-formed thesis in the start of the essay, which made the rest of the essay seem jumbled and random, as there was no real claim to relate it back to. It was also less than 1 ½ pages, a hilariously short amount of space in which to get a whole AP essay. The concept of a foil was not clear in the essay, which suggests that the author itself might not have truly known the definition of the term in the first place. Other than claiming that Baba highlighted Hassans good qualities, none of the claims the author made really seemed to answer the prompt in the way that was expected. As the AP grade said, the style of the essay was overly “simplistic”, which is why it received a measly 4/9. I guess the graders were feeling generous that grading day.



Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Summary and Analysis- Death of a Salesman

The Fairly Basic Theme
Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests that to value the words of others over their actions leads to a delusional perception of one’s own success, and that to focus on dreams and the past rather than reality and the future leads to the deterioration of family and oneself.

Death of a Salesman displays the deterioration of a highly dysfunctional family whose problems are chillingly basic and relatable in their simplicity; the entire family relies too heavily on the prospect of dreams. No one really does so much as thinks about doing and this, among other factors, leads to their downfall.
The play is set in a variety of places, primarily the Loman house in Brooklyn, but also the various locations he visits around there, including New York City itself.

Symbols-
The phonograph serves an example of Willy’s reluctance to fully come to terms with the past. This device records what is said word for word; with it, there is no room for interpretation or misperception, so denial is unachievable. Being that Willy lives for denial, this device horrifies him and brings him hard and fast into reality, something that he cannot handle.
The seeds that Willy keeps trying to plant represent his desperate desire to cultivate something lively within his life. The fact that they will not grow displays the Loman family’s lack of qualities that allow success to flourish.
Whenever Willy sees Linda mending her stockings, he gets incredibly upset and anxious; stockings were the gifts he gave his mistress, so when he sees his wife with them, it reminds him of his infidelity to her.

Plot-

Death of a Salesman recounts the slow and steady decline of Willy Loman’s person and his eventual suicide. In his old age, he never managed to attain the success he dreamed for himself throughout his life and this disappointment along with a number of other factors lead to his decision. He has constant flashbacks to his happier past with his family as he tries to reconcile with the present. His two sons are failures who cannot provide him a source of hope before it is too late, especially his oldest son, Biff. Willy has an ever-present guilt for Biff’s finding out about an affair he had many years earlier, and blames that and himself for Biff’s failing to amount to a useful son. Upon losing his thankless job and learning that his sons’ business ventures have failed, Willy ultimately decides that the only way he can achieve the success and glory he has been searching for his whole life is through the ultimate sacrifice. With the convincing of the figment of his brother in his mind, Willy decides to kill himself, which in turn presents his family with an enormous check. In many ways, he thinks of this quote as for Biff, the son he wronged in so many ways.

Characters-

Willy Loman is completely consumed with the past, primarily because he could never come to terms with the exact time when his happy family broke apart irreparably. From the moment his prodigal son discovered Willy’s affair with another woman, the bright and successful future they were all hoping for vanished. At the time during which the play is written—the days before Willy’s “sacrificial” suicide—Willy has constant flashbacks to the time before that fateful event, his way of reconciling the past with the present, which he never truly does. He is unkind to his wife and in many ways, crippled by the guilt he feels for singlehandedly throwing both his own life and those of his sons off track with his actions in the past. When things don’t appear to be able to improve in the lives of his family, Willy decides that to commit suicide and allow his family to collect the life insurance that would come of it is the only viable option.
Biff Loman is a product of broken dreams, and his outlook on life is completely different compared to that of his father, Willy’s. He believes that it is essential to accept one’s lot in life without question; he doesn’t believe himself able to achieve success, so he never will. In comparison, Willy always had hope and a desire for success, even when he no longer had reason to. Before he found out about his father’s affair, Biff had a considerably bright future playing football and making his beloved father proud. He allowed his discovery to destroy every bit of promise he had in him; it caused him to give up on life.
Happy Loman is Biff’s brother. His name is appropriately fitting to his character; he is for all intents and purposes a happy person, without much concern for anything in life. Many of his traits resemble those of his father; he likes women, he thinks himself as more important than he really is, and he has empty and false ambitions similar to Willy’s.
Linda Loman is Willy’s wife. She is revered by her sons, especially Biff, and treated considerably unfairly by her husband. She is wise and sees all that is going on with Willy and with her children, yet neglects to do anything about it. A perfect example of the recurring theme of “Too little too late” in the play, when she discovers evidence of Willy’s desire to kill himself, she does nothing about it, not wishing to diminish his pride.
Ben Loman is Willy’s older and much more successful brother. One of Willy’s deepest regrets in life is not having gone into business with Ben, who made it big mining in Africa. Ben is a rugged character who represents the value of a self-made man.
Charley is Willy’s only friend, though their relationship is fairly business-casual in nature. Willy borrows money to pay off his various household expenses every week from Charley, and declines him when he offers him a job at his company. He is a bit of a foil for Willy in that he is successful and happy in his life.
Bernard is Charley’s son, a successful and driven young man the same age as Biff. His life serves as an exact foil to Biff’s for he actually made something of himself and has a healthy relationship with his father.
Harold is Willy’s boss and shares uncomfortable similarities with Willy as a younger man. Inferred from the recordings on his phonograph, Harold is not incredibly nice to his wife, thinks very highly of his son, and is very involved with his job. He ends up firing Willy and figuratively ends his life, pushing him to suicide.
The Woman is the one Willy had his affair with; she is part of the reason Biff gave up on existence.

Quotes:
“Yes! Yes. Coming! It’s very smart, you realize that, don’t you sweetheart? Even Ben sees it. I gotta go, baby. Bye! Bye! Imagine? When the mail comes he’ll be ahead of Bernard again.” When Willy says this, he has just decided on suicide as the only alternative to saving his family. The money they will receive will be more than enough for them to live comfortably. In reality, though, he is really only doing this for Biff, his one loose end in the world. With this money, he hopes to win back his affection. (pg. 108)
"Terrific. Terrific job, boys. Good work, Biff." (pg. 17) 
This quote displays Willy's affinity for nondescript adjectives such as "terrific" and "remarkable" and also his reverence of Biff. He cannot commend both of his boys equally; Biff is forever the golden child, though he never amounts to anything. 


Motifs-
Lying
Exhaustion
Disconnection from reality
Dreams
Denial
Individualism
Loss of self-worth
Broken promises
Inability to let go of the past

Narrative Voice:
Arthur Miller was a Jewish man married to a Christian woman at the time that he wrote DoS, and several religious themes such as sin and prodigal sons come to light in the play. Otherwise, the play simply serves to expose broken family values brought about by personal failures and shortcomings that are subject to any person. 

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Close Reading Analysis #3


Slate columnist L.V Anderson's article detailing a Saskatchewan restaurant's decision to call one of its burgers the "Crack Pepper Burger" in an obvious jab at Rob Ford, the mayor of Toronto, whose personal crack problem has grown in media popularity over the past few weeks. In the article, Anderson uses advanced diction, dual-meaning language, and conversational syntax in order to express the humor intended in the message of the story itself.
The author's choice of diction varies throughout the piece but is marked most obviously through her use of interspersed "big words" within fairly simple sentences. In her introduction to the subject of the article, Anderson writes "creating stunt burgers—beef patties surrounded by deep-fried Twinkies, for instance—is a hackneyed affront to everything a burger should be." The use of mock-elevated diction, as seen with her use of the phrase "hackneyed affront" provides a bit of tongue-in-cheek humoring regarding the simultaneously offensive and ridiculous topic at hand. (Which is, of course, the mayor's drug addiction)
Language serves as the main vector through which Anderson's humor is expressed. Using words and phrases that have double meaning, a bit of authorial humor is tacked on to the situational humor already present in the events of the story itself. When she writes "but Rob Ford’s “tribute hamburger,” as Grub Street called it, is not nearly as tasteless as it sounds," and by following that up with a comment on the dual meaning of the word tasteless, Anderson uses the presence of homonyms in our language (Tasteless: classless and tasteless; without taste in a literal sense) to further extend the humor of her article. 


Lastly, Anderson's decision to write her article using conversational syntax provides a more relateable feel on the reader's behalf that allows the humorous nature of the story to be better put across. Using informal punctuation such as exclamation points-- "It alludes to the fact that Rob Ford actually, indisputably smoked crack!" and parenthetical asides such as "(“Tasteless” in the sense of “offensive,” that is; not living in or near Regina, Saskatchewan, I can’t vouch for how delicious it is.)", the tone of the article is kept light-hearted and sufficiently respectful while detailing such a darkly funny and slightly serious topic. This also works to provide a juxtaposition of the two situations present in the article; the grave matter of the mayor's crack problem and the hilarious one of the restaurant's decision to make fun of it.