Sunday, February 9, 2014

A Second Attempt at an Open Prompt Essay

Prompt:  Comment on the function of a foil in a piece of literature of your choice.

In literature, foils are typically characters secondary to the main character that serve to highlight his or her strengths and weaknesses. Shakespeare is well known for his use of foils, especially in Hamlet. In this particular play, several foils--specifically, Hamlet and Laertes, Ophelia and Gertrude, and Hamlet and Claudius--arise whose opposite actions and personas help us understand different characters at a deeper level.
When the ghost of Hamlet's father requests that Hamlet avenge his murder at the beginning of the play, the remainder of the story revolves around Hamlet's tortured deliberation as to whether or not he should obey his father and murder his uncle; in fact, this indecision is a defining characteristic of Hamlet's. When Laertes learns of his father's murder by Hamlet's hand, in contrast, he immediately returns to Elsinore, desperate to seek revenge on the man who killed his father. The enduring loyalty and decisiveness displayed by Laertes when he is put into more or less the exact same situation as Hamlet emphasizes the fact that Hamlet himself completely lacks these qualities.
As the only two female characters in Hamlet, Ophelia and Gertrude's characters are quite opposite to each other. Often referred to as the "virgin-whore" complex, the two's personalities represent the two prevailing notions of female behavior in Shakespeare's time. While Ophelia is loyal to her father and fairly innocent in demeanor, Gertrude's quick remarriage to her late-husband's brother implies her to be more of a sexual deviant, behavior that is condemned by Hamlet throughout the play. In many ways, the opposite characteristics of these two women serve to sum up Elizabethan England's various perceptions of women.
Hamlet and Claudius are defined in many ways by the qualities that one possesses that the other does not. For example, Hamlet's value of loyalty and morality contrast sharply to Claudius disregard of natural law, which he displays in the murder of his own brother. While Claudius is rather skilled at maintaining his composure when necessary, Hamlet is subject to breaking under pressure and allowing his true feelings to come to the surface, as is clear through the debate of his madness throughout the play. Though neither character is truly morally superior in any way, the differences in values between the two are important to consider when profiling the two men.

3 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bella,
    Wow nice job on this! You made some great points in this, especially for this being our second try at these. You clearly understood the prompt and had good examples from Hamlet. I was really impressed you were able to provide 3 sets of foils. However, the one thing I would say is try adding more about the overall meaning. Holmes is always talking about how important that is in every essay. You started to get there at the end of each paragraph but just go a little deeper. How do these foils add to the overall meaning of Hamlet? Also make sure your arguments don't conflict one another. In one foil you said Hamlet lacks loyalty and in the other one said he is loyal. I loved how you related Ophelia and Gertrude to Elizabethan times...very impressive. Like I said this was really good and if this is your second try, by the time the AP roles around you will be fantastic!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella,
    You did a good job. Your opening paragraph and thesis statement do not deviate from the prompt and answered the question in a straightforward and clear manner. The examples you had were appropriate as well.
    However, there are things that I would like to see to make your essays better. As Avery mentioned, bringing how the foils build to the meaning of the piece would greatly enhance the quality of this essay. Expand, enhance, delve deeper into your arguments, your evidence. Your body paragraphs are bordering on just presenting the evidence and saying "Here it is! Have fun!". It is like you are stating something rather than supporting it. I would be better to have only two examples that are thoroughly developed and supported than three mediocre, sub-par paragraphs that are true.
    I know that I am not really one to talk, since my essays are like eating trampled dirt, but that is the advice I have to give.

    ReplyDelete