*My sincerest apologies for the late post, Ms. Holmes. I was incapacitated by a mysterious illness on Sunday and Monday and didn't have the energy to watch Netflix, let alone complete homework efficiently. Do forgive me.*
Our past month as an AP family has been devoted to all things Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead. We finished our in-class reading of the play, watched the film, and annotated a lecture on the subject that frankly made me want to throw myself upon a sword.
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern was everything I'd hoped it would be. Discussing the implications of its symbols and commentary on existence as a class in incredibly fun, yet also slightly confusing as it appears that coming to a resolute consensus on any of the questions pitched to us is next to impossible. I'm sure that with further time to discuss and consider pirates and boats on our own, however, we'll come to some earth-shattering conclusions.
Watching the film allowed us to with R&G in a completely different dimension that I think helped with our understanding immensely. The fact that it was directed by Stoppard himself allowed us to make accurate connections between the play and the film because, of course, both were created by the same person. As far as understanding which characters exist in the various realities present in the story, I think the visual representation allowed us to better understand what Stoppard was trying to convey to us as opposed to just reading it aloud in class.
Holmes, as we all know, is the puppet master. She owns all of our souls and can control how we think, thus giving her the ability to sway our minds one way or another depending on how she's feeling that day. This is apparent with our reading and annotating of the Stoppard lecture. My confusion grew as I delved farther and farther into the reading, and by the last page I had become infuriated with the author and every point he made in his useless 12 page analysis. To say that he was merely delighted by R&G, as if it were an adorable little production put on by his daughter's third grade class, and not moved in any way is borderline insulting. To everyone. How could the abundance of symbolism and references to the very nature of existence, (And in many ways, I thought, religion) not move someone?
It was then I realized that Holmes was challenging our thinking, daring us to disagree with the material put in front of us. Rarely have the majority of the classes I've taken asked us to engage with rather than simply absorb any required reading, so I found it refreshing that Holmes didn't give us this lecture and tell us to memorize its points, but rather consider it and compare its ideas with our own. Reason #237 Why I love this class.
Aside from all of the R&G, we also did some much-needed practice with open prompts and intros to our essays. Though I think many of us felt terrified and under-prepared when faced with the idea of writing our own questions and constructing coherent intro paragraphs in a limited amount of time, I think it was an exercise we all benefited from in the long run. Surely by the time May rolls around and we're all in a constant state of panic over our upcoming exam, the prospect of timed essay writing will seem slightly less scary. Or at least we will all be significantly better prepared to take on the task.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBella,
ReplyDeleteGreat job on this! You made some great connections and it is clear you are really taking every part of this class as a new challenge which is awesome. I agree that the movie was worth while to watch. I loved your comments on how Holmes owns our mind. We had the exact same reaction to the lecture in our class. We were sitting there tearing this guy apart and Holmes finally told us that was the point, to let us challenge the literary critics. In regards to the hope of finding one conclusion we never were able to reach that. Did your class ever reach consensus? Overall I love how into this class you are! It is one of my favorites too and its cool to read your take on everything we are doing.
Bella,
ReplyDeleteI'm glad that you find such 'delight' in "Rosencrantz and Guildernstern Are Dead". It was such a 'delightful' little play, and really loved the 'delightful' language and themes that Stoppard uses as well. Simply 'delightful'.
What I found most interesting in your post, however, was a rather humorous contradiction. You say that Ms Holmes is a "puppet master" who seems to "own all of our souls" and such. Yet later, you say that Ms Holmes assigned us the lecture to "challenge" our thinking. So we learn to challenge opinions to sharpen our own by bowing down to the will of another? Not that I want to dissuade you from building a cult of personality, but the two ideas kind of conflict. I really hope that you will read this and respond, because I hate being ignored after putting this much effort in.