Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt #4

Tragic Figures as Instruments for the Suffering of Others

Open Prompt Question 3, 2003

Essay #1
The first essay did well with regard to pulling ample amounts of textual evidence from The Great Gatsby and making connections between the prompt and the novel. However, the student had quite a few problems with sticking to one tense and in identifying pronouns clearly in the writing. It also misused several words, significantly so when it claimed that "Gatsby catered to the pandering rich". This sentence doesn't make sense; clearly the writer either wasn't sure what it was trying to say or didn't know what the word 'pander' means. In general, though, the claims made and the ties between "the three scales of tragedy- personal, inter-personal, and societal" were all well supported and clear to any reader familiar or unfamiliar with the novel. The amount of quotes used from The Great Gatsby made me genuinely wonder if the student had the book on hand while completing this essay. I would assume he or she did not, making the whole thing significantly more impressive. Aside from a few grammar and word choice mistakes, I would agree with the College Board's high grade of this essay, as it was certainly better that its successors.

Essay #2
This essay only hurt to read slightly, which is an accomplishment compared to some of the others I've encountered. Its structure wasn't ideal and seemed to have little flow of ideas. Points were disjointed and the writing as a whole lacked several main points that it was trying to convey. Though the essay was supposed to be connecting the character of King Lear to the concept of tragic figures, it trailed off and began discussing other characters in the play, even throwing in a thought about Hamlet at one point. Humorous, yes. Points winning, not on the AP English exam. It was difficult to figure out exactly how and in what ways King Lear was considered tragic. The student discussed his greed and vanity, an excellent trait that leads to a tragic demise, but seemed to only repeat this and didn't really come to new conclusions about his character as the essay went on, stopping to discuss his daughters along the way. A paragraph about what the king represented by having the traits would have likely been useful, in my opinion. The student received a 7 on this essay, which I think was fair. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't professional.

Essay #3
Flimsy to say the least, the third essay was nothing special. It claimed that McMurphey was a good example of a tragic figure, but neglected to acknowledge several undercurrents of the novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It listed several instances when McMurphey's actions affected the other characters negatively, but many of these seemed to serve other reasons in the novel than to display tragedy. Before McMurphey joined the mental ward, many of the patients were leading listless, boring lives, and his arrival changed their lives by adding some excitement. The fact that this argument can be made makes his character not entirely fit for the role of a tragic figure. Aside from this, the student's writing style and syntax was simple without much variation. The essay itself contained a few fragments as well. Collectively, I think the essay's score of a 5 was justified, and it most certainly could have been thought out more.


Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading #I stopped counting


A hilarious narrative of a childhood faux-pas, Elizabeth Weingarten's article about the time she, a young Jewish girl, believed she had revealed the big secret of Santa's inexistence to a fellow 3rd grade classmate. The incident apparently haunted her into her adult life, where she finally contacted the girl whose life she believed to have ruined through her callous disclosure of the truth. Weingarten's article uses colorful imagery, dynamic syntax, and educated language and diction to convey a message of humor to readers. 
The point of Weingarten's piece was to tell a story and, as is crucial to good storytelling, contained vivid imagery. The author opens her retelling of the event with a description of its setting: "During one December art class, groups gathered around long, paint-splattered tables, coloring with broken crayons and chewed markers". This creates a playful, childish mood and paints a picture that just about everyone can relate to their youth in school. Other sections convey the message through humorous imagery. As the author laments her actions, she writes “Does [the girl] think of me each year by the Christmas tree, her eggnog made bitter by the memory of the day I took an axe to her childish sense of awe and wonder?” Sentences like these add imagination and comical mental imagery that work to make the article more engaging.
            The dynamic syntax of the article works namely to humorous ends, often leading into certain ‘punch lines’ in various structures. One of these methods involves a colon, and example of which being “Each year, around Christmas, I recall the events of that afternoon and wonder: Did my gaffe kill part of her hopeful, glittering soul?” The simple lead to the sentences sets up a comical end with the colon that adds to the overall humor of the piece. Another method the author uses is indenting certain sentences in order to add a subtle emphasis to the humor intended at that specific part of the article:

“What, exactly, was the appalling crime of these two women? They both denied the existence of Santa Claus. Now, they’re paying for it.
I feel their pain.”
This ensures that a reader’s eye takes in the passage in a specific way, which in turn emphasizes humor.
The language of the piece exemplifies something that is quite common with the writer’s at Slate. Though the articles are simplistic stylistically, the word choice and overall tone of the pieces are highly educated and work to make reading them pleasing to the mind to read. When talking about what it was like to know about the inexistence of Santa, Weingarten says she felt “deliciously superior”, an unusual term that stands out in the writing and catches a reader’s attention. One sentence in particular stands out as having specifically quality diction and overall language: “But even the occasional verbal slip-up does little to erode a kid’s ironclad belief.” Strong words like ‘erode’ and ‘ironclad’ paired with the simple syntax of the sentence make it interesting to read and add to the enjoyable nature of the article. 
The writing style used in Weingarten's article allowed it to come off as simple, sweet, and funny. The author's use of varied syntax, vivid imagery and professional language and diction all worked to engage the reader and keep the article entertaining. 

Response to Course Material #3

I've been gone for a long time. Like, a really long time. The following is my attempt to reflect on course material that we covered over a month ago. I would have tried to have completed it sooner, but I was quite busy and generally Wifi-less during my time in South Africa. I do hope this is comprehensive enough.


In addition to completing Death of a Salesman and beginning Hamlet, we did a number of in-class writing an analysis activities in class over the past month. In reading The Century Quilt and completing two essays discussing the meaning of the poem, we learned how to take a deeper look at what DIDLS work to convey in writing to the reader. When we read and discussed the poem as a class and wrote a secondary essay, we discovered much more to write about than in the initial reading we did on our own. It's my hope that by the end of the year, we will learn to make such quality observances on our way without the need to be helped along by our teacher or our classmates. I suppose that's more or less the point of the course.
We also worked on our second classwork of choosing an image and attempting to summarize it in a couple of sentences centered around one conceptual word. As a writer, I highly enjoyed this activity as it exemplifies how difficult it is for writers to convey whatever they see in their minds into written word. I also think it allows us to see how difficult it is to create quality syntax and properly describe setting. In past English classes we have been asked to recreate things through writing, but the way we do so in this class is certainly more tailored to the exam and focuses more highly on techniques than content.
As for DOS, we finished up the play and had a few fishbowls about the various symbols and ideas present in the work. While fishbowls are certainly interesting methods of inducing discussion, I much prefer whole class discussions. It's better when everyone has the chance to express their thoughts and receive feedback rather than have to wait and listen 4 select few blather on. (Because really, after a while of being in that bowl, people begin to get stir-crazy and losing quality of content in their ideas) Ultimately, though, I'm glad we experienced varying methods of discussion, simply because the depth of content in DOS required a lot of consideration on our parts, and it was good to be able to analyze it in several different ways.
Now, I found Hamlet to be quite an interesting piece.I love Shakespeare and his language in general, so naturally the lyrical language of Hamlet was music to my ears, but as for the plot, it was not my favorite of the tragedies. We read Macbeth in British Lit last year, which I highly enjoyed, but while Hamlet too had its fair share of deep characters and tragic deaths, it was not enough to knock Macbeth out from its place as my second favorite Shakespearean tragedy. (The first being Romeo and Juliet; not because I'm a hopeless romantic, but because I find the language in that particular play to be simply spellbinding)
I found our discussions of the play, along with Ms. Holmes' colorful supplemental information to be quite helpful. There is a lot to this play, obviously, in the vein of references in symbolism so I think a good amount of in class analysis is necessary to ensure we all leave with a concrete understanding of the work. I have faith that this will be the case in the coming weeks, especially as we begin our annotations. Close reading is always helpful.