After
taking Peterson’s AP English poetry
test, I've recognized that my biggest weakness with regard to poetry is recognition
of figurative language. I frequently mixed up the definitions of metaphor,
personification, conceit, etc. In a few of the questions, I found myself running
into terms I’m not even remotely familiar with, such as synecdoche. My other weaknesses include identifying speakers and themes in poetry, respectively. I
noticed the former in the first poem, La Belle
Dame Sans Merci. When asked about the specific change in perspective in the poem at a certain stanza, I struggled to identify what it was and got the question wrong. With regard to questions asking to identify the themes of the poems, I sometimes had trouble analyzing each of the choices given properly. Two of the options often sounded correct, and it was difficult to decide on just one. While I'm very good at understanding symbols and language, I will have to work on my figure of speech knowledge and identification of themes.
Monday, August 12, 2013
Blog Post #1- An Analysis of Peterson's Diagnostic Test
Overall,
I didn’t find the practice test all too challenging, which is why I was
surprised to find that I had misinterpreted a good bit of the questions. Upon
checking my answers and reading through the explanations, I understood my
errors but nonetheless wondered where exactly I went wrong with my thinking. It
seems my biggest strength is being able to understand meaning and symbols while
my biggest weakness is in relation to the literal aspects of writing and the
genre placement of poetry/literature.
A Valediction: Forbidden Mourning made sense to me as I read it several times. I
understood the conceits and the meaning of the poem, which detailed a person
who must leave his lover but is confident their love will survive time apart.
That being said, I answered all of the questions about figurative language and
subjects correctly, but somehow completely misunderstood the tone of the poem.
I said that it was melancholy, when the real answer was sanguine, which is more
or less the polar opposite of melancholy. I can attribute my error in
comprehension to my having read too heavily into the word choice used in the
poem rather than the prevailing theme itself. I focused on phrases such as ‘forbidden
mourning’ and ‘virtuous men pass mildly away’ which, when paired with the
obvious theme of lovers who must part, made me think of melancholy. Had I
thought about the way the speaker was comforting his lover and talking about
how one day he will come back to her, sanguine would have been the obvious
choice for me.
The
other issue I had with this section was in trying to place it under a certain
genre of poetry. While I am loosely familiar with the different types of poems
and their descriptions, I still struggled to answer the various questions
relating to them throughout the test. I answered that Forbidden Mourning was narrative rather than a lyric. I understood
why it was indeed a lyric when I checked my answers, but I’m nonetheless
uncertain as to what the specific differences in all the poetry genres are.
The
excerpt from Pride and Prejudice was
my most successful part of the test. I found that I am good at dissecting
dialogue and character analysis. I understood the dynamic between Mr. and Mrs.
Bennet, how he was relaxed and had a quiet sort of wit about him while she was
a typical obsessive middle-class mother. I was lacking in the parts that
required me to prescribe meaning to the conversation itself, though. When asked
to characterize the excerpt, I said that it was a satire of the Bennets’
personal relationship when it was really considered to be just a simple
conversation about a new neighbor and how his presence might affect the family.
This indicates to me that I might read to closely into things. When asked what
the story might turn into, I marked it as a criticism of the middle class when
the correct answer was a genial satire. I consider this another example of my
tendency to consider details too closely when the answer lies in the big
picture.
My
interpretation of Night Clouds was
fairly accurate. I understood the point of the poem, identified the playful
tone, and could define the symbols correctly. This made me feel confident in my
ability to analyze poetry and understand the meaning behind word choices and
analogies. My only struggle here was, again, trying to define the poem itself.
I called it a narrative when it was really a lyric, just as I did with the
first poem. I also described the phrase ‘tiger sun’ as it was used in the poem
as personification rather than figurative language. Though I see my error in
this, I think I need to brush up on my poetry language knowledge as a whole.
Modern American Poetry, A Critical Anthology was likely the excerpt with which I struggled the
most. I think reading through it a few more times would have helped me answer
the questions a lot better. The fact that the topic of the piece was rather dry
and scholarly and the writing style was so essay-like made it a bit hard for me
to concentrate and take in the information, something I definitely need to work
on. I noticed while looking at my answers that I changed my answer referring to
the interpretation of the thesis multiple times and ended up getting it wrong
when my first answer was already correct. While questions about the text in a
broad sense were difficult for me, those asking about specific passages or
sentences were easy for me to put into context. For instance, when asked about
what changed the role of the Brahmins, I incorrectly answered the industrial
movement when it was really the Civil War. This should have been obvious to me,
but I again looked too deeply into the text rather than taking it in as a
whole. When asked to define the phrase ‘reechoeings of the old music’, though,
I understood and got the question right because it was a specific part of the
text that didn’t require me to look at the big picture, which I have a pattern
of not doing efficiently.
Altogether
I think that taking this test gave me a better understanding of what to expect in
the class and also in the AP exam itself. I’m confident that with enough
practice I will improve my weaknesses and also sharpen my strengths. I
understand which aspects of literature analysis I need to focus on more and
which I need to focus on less, which I am sure will help me succeed later on in
the class.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)