Right, let's get to it then.
In the past month or so, we finished our Ros and Guil discussions, which truthfully left me feeling rather incomplete. We came up with some solid conclusions as to what the play is/is not trying to say, but I remain unconvinced that I fully understand it. Thus, I truly believe that Stoppard wrote this play just to mess with his readers' minds. It is so soaked in meaning, yet this meaning appears to be entirely up to interpretation.
It's hard to put that into a theme statement, however. That was a very irritating task, to say the least.
The Postmodern reading we did certainly helped with comprehension, with its discussion of concepts like ambiguity, complexity, and the conflicting nature of language within Ros&Guil. At the end of the day, though, I feel as though I'll have to read the play several times before I can make qualified remarks about it.
Now that we've started reading out first book, Ceremony, 'tis an exciting time in the kingdom. We did some preliminary reading on the subject in class with the Silko essays and the Tayo's World presentation, which I'm sure will assist us greatly in our comprehension of the novel later on. I quite enjoy it thus far, especially the writing--however, I can't help but dread the day when annotating time comes round. I'm not sure I'm emotionally prepared to properly annotate an entire book. Thank God for therapy.
Our review of critical lenses has been rather helpful. Having taken both British and American Lit, I already had a considerable amount of prior knowledge on the subject, but the Powerpoint really solidified and expanded my understanding of the various lenses. Last year, I wrote a paper analyzing Clockwork Orange through an archetypal lens, but I feel like I'm far better informed on the subject now, and if I were to go back and redo it now it would likely sound far more sophisticated and, well, intelligent.
Having several days dedicated to freely analyzing all of the plays we read through lenses of our choice has been interesting, to say the least. My class stumbled our way around a sad discussion of The American Dream as interpreted through a feminist lens, and then moved on to psychoanalyzing the characters of Hamlet, which led to greater success. I think it's interesting that the various classes have such differing ideas about the plays; when we all come together to share them during that project thing Holmes vaguely mentioned to us, I'm sure our minds will be all types of blown.
As for actual classwork, we wrote a closed-prompt essay on Twelve, which really emphasized for me the fact that I really need to work on my time management skills. As painful as in-class essays are, I know that they are highly important for us to do if we want to score anything near a respectable score on the exam. Which is in less than two months. Let the anxiety dreams commence.
We also analyzed "Defending Walt Whitman", which apparently took my class about a day longer than it did for the others. This is mostly because we tend to get hung up on one aspect of our analyses and discuss it for too long rather than identifying several concepts and exploring them all lightly and equally. Again, for the time sensitive AP, this is something we must work on.
Oh, and then there was the mythoi discussion in class with the whole circular nature of seasons/romance/tragedy thing, which helped us understand the cycle of character journeys. Do see Max's blog for a visual representation of that in doughnut form.
Right, I second that recommendation on the Max's blog/mythoi doughnut thingie.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Bella, this entry is a bit uneven. There are spots where I'm right with you--where I see genuine processing of the material happening ("which really emphasized for me the fact that I really need to work on my time management skills," "we tend to get hung up on one aspect of our analyses," etc.) And then there are places where I can just SMELL the insincerity, the oh-Holmes-said-to-make-"connections"-so-here-whatever. Like the bit about the Clockwork Orange paper. If you'd known more at the time you'd have written a better paper? Um... Come on, Bella--that's not even your best b.s. Can you say specifically what you would have changed? Or what you understand now that you didn't understand then?
Bella,
ReplyDeleteThank you for pointing out the obvious problem with interpreting "Rosencrantz and Guildenstern", that so many meanings can be extracted from the play that it becomes increasingly difficult to pin down anything concrete. This is the main problem I had with the work, which I devoured voraciously and enjoyed every minute of, but still had a lingering question in the back of my head: "if it can mean anything, then doesn't it mean nothing?" I certainly don't think that the play is meaningless, even if Stoppard wrote it just to troll his audience, but there are many other pieces of Modernist and Postmodernist works that resist interpretation simply for the sake of audience participation. I talked about it more in my own post, but you see what I'm saying. It was frustrating for hour class to pin something down too, so we scrapped the idea of writing a grand unified theme statement and left each person to his own devices. Your comments on time management are particularly resonant; I am awful at managing time. If I had my way, I'd tear the whole system down to its roots and rebuild something that doesn't just test how well you can write within forty minutes, but I don't have that luxury. Maybe you and I can go out into the world and revolutionize AP Literature testing for generations of unborn students to come; it is our holy duty and cause to do so.