*So, uh, as an effect of my African truancy stunt, I was only here for two weeks of school in December and therefore I'm sure I missed quite a few important things necessary for this blog post. I also haven't had Internet for the past week or so- an absolutely horrifying experience, wouldn't recommend it- which is why this is late*
I was present for three of the five Hamlet films we watched in class: Olivier's, Jacobi's, and Hawke's. It's a shame I missed the others, I'm sure they were glorious. It was interesting to see the various adaptations of Hamlet from the stage to the screen and, more specifically, what directors chose to emphasize with regard to the important plot elements of the play.
Olivier's interpretation was extremely well done. It held the alluring quality that most black and white films tend to have, which worked well in playing up the darker elements of the play. Hamlet was appropriately aged in what appeared to be his mid-thirties, which made the whole Oedipus complex thing with his not-too-much-older mother slightly more believable/disturbing. The directing style was also full of symbolism, portraying Elsinore as a lonely, secluded place on a cliff, teetering both literally and figuratively on the edge of destruction. The eerie shots of the castle's stairways and corridors added added a flare of mystery, coming together in the end with Hamlet's somber funeral march up the mountain, a fairly obvious allusion to his ascent to heaven.
Hawke's rip-off of Baz Luhrman's directing style in Romeo and Juliet was insulting to say the least, and the film itself just didn't do much for me. The corporate setting was original, I suppose, but just didn't fit the plot too well for my tastes. I did however enjoy the way Ophelia and Hamlet's relationship was portrayed. It came off as much more accessible, and as an audience we could relate to the scenes that displayed their struggles and conflicting emotions much better than compared to the other films. The scenes with the ghost could have been better, I think; they were a bit understated, but then again so were many other parts of the film.
Also, Ethan Hawke just irks me in general, so that probably adds to my discontent with the production itself.
Jacobi's version was forgettable; the set was wrong, the acting was unimpressive, and it was simply a play being filmed rather than a new interpretation of a classic story. We also watched Shakespeare Uncovered, which was told to us by a Scottish man with a funny little accent/haircut. It exposed some rather interesting facts, such as the name of Shakespeare's lost son and how that may have influenced his writing of the play.
I thoroughly enjoyed annotating "Tragic Balance in Hamlet"; I found the essay intriguing and exceedingly informative, as it referenced so many other Shakespearean scholars and their interpretations on various themes of the play. It really opened my eyes and helped me with my annotations, which I was still working on at the time.
Bella,
ReplyDeleteIt is sad that you had to miss the David Tennant and Kenneth Branagh interpretations of Hamlet, and if you ever see them I would be interested to hear your thoughts on those. I like how you went into why you liked or disliked each version that you saw and I have to agree that I really liked how Hamlet and Ophelia’s relationship was portrayed in the Hawke version despite not liking the movie as a whole. It’s great that you mentioned the Shakespeare Uncovered documentary; I forgot to mention that in mine and haven’t seen it in many other posts. What really caught my attention about this post is that you enjoyed the “Tragic Balance in Hamlet” article. Personally I couldn’t stand it and found it very confusing to read and much overwritten. You are the first person I’ve heard or read about liking this article. Though I can see where you are coming from with the “many other Shakespearean scholars and their interpretations on various themes of the play” I found them to be a bit much and just proceeded to hide what the author was trying to say. Great job again; I think the only thing you didn’t mention was the Shakespeare forum posts and I would have liked to know your opinions on those.
Dear Bella,
ReplyDeleteYou're exactly right about the Hawke's version of Hamlet being just awful. Luhrman's Romeo + Juliet was charming, but Hawke should just be embarrassed. It really is too bad you didn't see the Tennant version; that one was my favorite. I think it was a much more successful attempt at a modern Hamlet, and it portrayed him as extremely eccentric and truly mad. Plus it took place in a really cool looking castle with sleek black tile and stuff. It's interesting that you said Jacobi's version was just a play being filmed, rather than a new take on the work. What if that was their intention? Maybe they wanted to make a "pure" portrayal based solely off of the text, not trying to blow anyone's mind. That was my impression. Caitlin's right, you didn't talk about the forum posts, and there was some good stuff in there. Shakespeare in prison, the bush, and then that Ophelia poem. It couldn't hurt to revisit those activities.