Tragic Figures as Instruments for the Suffering of Others
Open Prompt Question 3, 2003
Essay #1
The first essay did well with regard to pulling ample amounts of textual evidence from The Great Gatsby and making connections between the prompt and the novel. However, the student had quite a few problems with sticking to one tense and in identifying pronouns clearly in the writing. It also misused several words, significantly so when it claimed that "Gatsby catered to the pandering rich". This sentence doesn't make sense; clearly the writer either wasn't sure what it was trying to say or didn't know what the word 'pander' means. In general, though, the claims made and the ties between "the three scales of tragedy- personal, inter-personal, and societal" were all well supported and clear to any reader familiar or unfamiliar with the novel. The amount of quotes used from The Great Gatsby made me genuinely wonder if the student had the book on hand while completing this essay. I would assume he or she did not, making the whole thing significantly more impressive. Aside from a few grammar and word choice mistakes, I would agree with the College Board's high grade of this essay, as it was certainly better that its successors.
Essay #2
This essay only hurt to read slightly, which is an accomplishment compared to some of the others I've encountered. Its structure wasn't ideal and seemed to have little flow of ideas. Points were disjointed and the writing as a whole lacked several main points that it was trying to convey. Though the essay was supposed to be connecting the character of King Lear to the concept of tragic figures, it trailed off and began discussing other characters in the play, even throwing in a thought about Hamlet at one point. Humorous, yes. Points winning, not on the AP English exam. It was difficult to figure out exactly how and in what ways King Lear was considered tragic. The student discussed his greed and vanity, an excellent trait that leads to a tragic demise, but seemed to only repeat this and didn't really come to new conclusions about his character as the essay went on, stopping to discuss his daughters along the way. A paragraph about what the king represented by having the traits would have likely been useful, in my opinion. The student received a 7 on this essay, which I think was fair. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't professional.
Essay #3
Flimsy to say the least, the third essay was nothing special. It claimed that McMurphey was a good example of a tragic figure, but neglected to acknowledge several undercurrents of the novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It listed several instances when McMurphey's actions affected the other characters negatively, but many of these seemed to serve other reasons in the novel than to display tragedy. Before McMurphey joined the mental ward, many of the patients were leading listless, boring lives, and his arrival changed their lives by adding some excitement. The fact that this argument can be made makes his character not entirely fit for the role of a tragic figure. Aside from this, the student's writing style and syntax was simple without much variation. The essay itself contained a few fragments as well. Collectively, I think the essay's score of a 5 was justified, and it most certainly could have been thought out more.
Sunday, December 15, 2013
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Close Reading #I stopped counting
A hilarious narrative of a childhood faux-pas, Elizabeth Weingarten's article about the time she, a young Jewish girl, believed she had revealed the big secret of Santa's inexistence to a fellow 3rd grade classmate. The incident apparently haunted her into her adult life, where she finally contacted the girl whose life she believed to have ruined through her callous disclosure of the truth. Weingarten's article uses colorful imagery, dynamic syntax, and educated language and diction to convey a message of humor to readers.
The point of Weingarten's piece was to tell a story and, as
is crucial to good storytelling, contained vivid imagery. The author opens her
retelling of the event with a description of its setting: "During
one December art class, groups gathered around long, paint-splattered tables,
coloring with broken crayons and chewed markers". This creates a
playful, childish mood and paints a picture that just about everyone can relate
to their youth in school. Other sections convey the message through
humorous imagery. As the author laments her actions, she writes “Does [the girl] think of me each year by
the Christmas tree, her eggnog made bitter
by the memory of the day I took an axe to her childish sense of awe and wonder?”
Sentences like these add imagination and comical mental imagery that work to
make the article more engaging.
The dynamic syntax of the article
works namely to humorous ends, often leading into certain ‘punch lines’ in
various structures. One of these methods involves a colon, and example of which
being “Each year, around Christmas, I
recall the events of that afternoon and wonder: Did my gaffe kill part of her
hopeful, glittering soul?” The simple lead to the sentences sets up
a comical end with the colon that adds to the overall humor of the piece.
Another method the author uses is indenting certain sentences in order to add a
subtle emphasis to the humor intended at that specific part of the article:
“What, exactly, was the appalling crime of these two women? They both denied the existence of Santa Claus. Now, they’re paying for it.
I feel their pain.”
This
ensures that a reader’s eye takes in the passage in a specific way, which in
turn emphasizes humor.
The language of the piece
exemplifies something that is quite common with the writer’s at Slate. Though the articles are simplistic
stylistically, the word choice and overall tone of the pieces are highly
educated and work to make reading them pleasing to the mind to read. When
talking about what it was like to know about the inexistence of Santa,
Weingarten says she felt “deliciously superior”, an unusual term that stands
out in the writing and catches a reader’s attention. One sentence in particular
stands out as having specifically quality diction and overall language: “But even the
occasional verbal slip-up does little to erode a kid’s ironclad belief.”
Strong words like ‘erode’ and ‘ironclad’ paired
with the simple syntax of the sentence make it interesting to read and add to
the enjoyable nature of the article. The writing style used in Weingarten's article allowed it to come off as simple, sweet, and funny. The author's use of varied syntax, vivid imagery and professional language and diction all worked to engage the reader and keep the article entertaining.
Response to Course Material #3
I've been gone for a long time. Like, a really long time. The following is my attempt to reflect on course material that we covered over a month ago. I would have tried to have completed it sooner, but I was quite busy and generally Wifi-less during my time in South Africa. I do hope this is comprehensive enough.
In addition to completing Death of a Salesman and beginning Hamlet, we did a number of in-class writing an analysis activities in class over the past month. In reading The Century Quilt and completing two essays discussing the meaning of the poem, we learned how to take a deeper look at what DIDLS work to convey in writing to the reader. When we read and discussed the poem as a class and wrote a secondary essay, we discovered much more to write about than in the initial reading we did on our own. It's my hope that by the end of the year, we will learn to make such quality observances on our way without the need to be helped along by our teacher or our classmates. I suppose that's more or less the point of the course.
We also worked on our second classwork of choosing an image and attempting to summarize it in a couple of sentences centered around one conceptual word. As a writer, I highly enjoyed this activity as it exemplifies how difficult it is for writers to convey whatever they see in their minds into written word. I also think it allows us to see how difficult it is to create quality syntax and properly describe setting. In past English classes we have been asked to recreate things through writing, but the way we do so in this class is certainly more tailored to the exam and focuses more highly on techniques than content.
As for DOS, we finished up the play and had a few fishbowls about the various symbols and ideas present in the work. While fishbowls are certainly interesting methods of inducing discussion, I much prefer whole class discussions. It's better when everyone has the chance to express their thoughts and receive feedback rather than have to wait and listen 4 select few blather on. (Because really, after a while of being in that bowl, people begin to get stir-crazy and losing quality of content in their ideas) Ultimately, though, I'm glad we experienced varying methods of discussion, simply because the depth of content in DOS required a lot of consideration on our parts, and it was good to be able to analyze it in several different ways.
Now, I found Hamlet to be quite an interesting piece.I love Shakespeare and his language in general, so naturally the lyrical language of Hamlet was music to my ears, but as for the plot, it was not my favorite of the tragedies. We read Macbeth in British Lit last year, which I highly enjoyed, but while Hamlet too had its fair share of deep characters and tragic deaths, it was not enough to knock Macbeth out from its place as my second favorite Shakespearean tragedy. (The first being Romeo and Juliet; not because I'm a hopeless romantic, but because I find the language in that particular play to be simply spellbinding)
I found our discussions of the play, along with Ms. Holmes' colorful supplemental information to be quite helpful. There is a lot to this play, obviously, in the vein of references in symbolism so I think a good amount of in class analysis is necessary to ensure we all leave with a concrete understanding of the work. I have faith that this will be the case in the coming weeks, especially as we begin our annotations. Close reading is always helpful.
In addition to completing Death of a Salesman and beginning Hamlet, we did a number of in-class writing an analysis activities in class over the past month. In reading The Century Quilt and completing two essays discussing the meaning of the poem, we learned how to take a deeper look at what DIDLS work to convey in writing to the reader. When we read and discussed the poem as a class and wrote a secondary essay, we discovered much more to write about than in the initial reading we did on our own. It's my hope that by the end of the year, we will learn to make such quality observances on our way without the need to be helped along by our teacher or our classmates. I suppose that's more or less the point of the course.
We also worked on our second classwork of choosing an image and attempting to summarize it in a couple of sentences centered around one conceptual word. As a writer, I highly enjoyed this activity as it exemplifies how difficult it is for writers to convey whatever they see in their minds into written word. I also think it allows us to see how difficult it is to create quality syntax and properly describe setting. In past English classes we have been asked to recreate things through writing, but the way we do so in this class is certainly more tailored to the exam and focuses more highly on techniques than content.
As for DOS, we finished up the play and had a few fishbowls about the various symbols and ideas present in the work. While fishbowls are certainly interesting methods of inducing discussion, I much prefer whole class discussions. It's better when everyone has the chance to express their thoughts and receive feedback rather than have to wait and listen 4 select few blather on. (Because really, after a while of being in that bowl, people begin to get stir-crazy and losing quality of content in their ideas) Ultimately, though, I'm glad we experienced varying methods of discussion, simply because the depth of content in DOS required a lot of consideration on our parts, and it was good to be able to analyze it in several different ways.
Now, I found Hamlet to be quite an interesting piece.I love Shakespeare and his language in general, so naturally the lyrical language of Hamlet was music to my ears, but as for the plot, it was not my favorite of the tragedies. We read Macbeth in British Lit last year, which I highly enjoyed, but while Hamlet too had its fair share of deep characters and tragic deaths, it was not enough to knock Macbeth out from its place as my second favorite Shakespearean tragedy. (The first being Romeo and Juliet; not because I'm a hopeless romantic, but because I find the language in that particular play to be simply spellbinding)
I found our discussions of the play, along with Ms. Holmes' colorful supplemental information to be quite helpful. There is a lot to this play, obviously, in the vein of references in symbolism so I think a good amount of in class analysis is necessary to ensure we all leave with a concrete understanding of the work. I have faith that this will be the case in the coming weeks, especially as we begin our annotations. Close reading is always helpful.
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Open Prompt Response 3
Prompt: Comment on the function of a foil in a piece
of literature of your choice.
Essay #1- As has become
typical for me upon reading these first essays, I found the student’s
description of the foils present in Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club to be lackluster at best. The language did not flow
very well, and the syntax of the overall piece was stiff. It appeared to me
that rather than focus on the specific character traits that supported his or
her claim that the two characters at hand were indeed foils, the author instead
more or less gave an entire synopsis of the novel in a three-page essay. This
essay of course got an 8, though, so the graders had to have seen something of
value in the writer’s tactic. I would say that perhaps the large amount of
textual evidence, sufficient foil-like connections between the two characters,
and author’s prudent series of restatements of the prompt throughout the essay
all contributed to it not being truly terrible. Personally, I would give it
more of a 6 for lack of clarity and truly well-developed ideas, but alas, I am
not a well-trained AP grader, so my opinion is not a valid one.
Essay #2- Not entirely
developed and lacking in coherent structure, this student’s essay knew what it
wanted to say, just not quite how to say it. Full of grammar errors and
fragmented sentences, the flow of the essay was off, making it difficult to
decipher who exactly the student thought Celie’s foil to be: her father or
‘Shug.’ While there was much textual evidence present to support the claims the
author made, it simply made too many. This lack of coherency lead to a less
valuable essay overall and is what I would think led to its lower score of a 6.
Though the author surely knew the meaning of a foil—it even introduced the
concept of Maslow’s hierarchy—the details it provided in attempt to support its
claims about the character’s path to self-actualization were too spread-out and
did not make obvious statements as to which character served as Celie’s foil.
It seemed in the beginning that Celie’s father was her foil, and in the middle
it appeared that it was instead Shug that taught Celie her important values.
But in the end, the author restated that it was indeed her father, a thought
process very confusing to the reader.
Essay #3- Beginning
with an intro that could have come from a mind with the scholarly intellect of
a six year old, the third essay was unpromising from the start. It neglected to
produce a well-formed thesis in the start of the essay, which made the rest of
the essay seem jumbled and random, as there was no real claim to relate it back
to. It was also less than 1 ½ pages, a hilariously short amount of space in
which to get a whole AP essay. The concept of a foil was not clear in the
essay, which suggests that the author itself might not have truly known the
definition of the term in the first place. Other than claiming that Baba
highlighted Hassans good qualities, none of the claims the author made really
seemed to answer the prompt in the way that was expected. As the AP grade said,
the style of the essay was overly “simplistic”, which is why it received a
measly 4/9. I guess the graders were feeling generous that grading day.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Summary and Analysis- Death of a Salesman
The
Fairly Basic Theme
Arthur
Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests
that to value the words of others over their actions leads to a delusional
perception of one’s own success, and that to focus on dreams and the past
rather than reality and the future leads to the deterioration of family and
oneself.
Death of a Salesman displays the deterioration of a highly dysfunctional family whose problems are chillingly basic and relatable in their simplicity; the entire family relies too heavily on the prospect of dreams. No one really does so much as thinks about doing and this, among other factors, leads to their downfall.
The play is set in a variety of places, primarily
the Loman house in Brooklyn, but also the various locations he visits around
there, including New York City itself.
Symbols-
The phonograph
serves an example of Willy’s reluctance to fully come to terms with the past.
This device records what is said word for word; with it, there is no room for
interpretation or misperception, so denial is unachievable. Being that Willy
lives for denial, this device horrifies him and brings him hard and fast into
reality, something that he cannot handle.
The seeds
that Willy keeps trying to plant represent his desperate desire to cultivate
something lively within his life. The fact that they will not grow displays the
Loman family’s lack of qualities that allow success to flourish.
Whenever Willy sees Linda mending her stockings, he gets incredibly upset and
anxious; stockings were the gifts he gave his mistress, so when he sees his
wife with them, it reminds him of his infidelity to her.
Plot-
Death of a Salesman recounts the slow and steady decline of Willy Loman’s person and his eventual suicide. In his old age, he never managed to attain the success he dreamed for himself throughout his life and this disappointment along with a number of other factors lead to his decision. He has constant flashbacks to his happier past with his family as he tries to reconcile with the present. His two sons are failures who cannot provide him a source of hope before it is too late, especially his oldest son, Biff. Willy has an ever-present guilt for Biff’s finding out about an affair he had many years earlier, and blames that and himself for Biff’s failing to amount to a useful son. Upon losing his thankless job and learning that his sons’ business ventures have failed, Willy ultimately decides that the only way he can achieve the success and glory he has been searching for his whole life is through the ultimate sacrifice. With the convincing of the figment of his brother in his mind, Willy decides to kill himself, which in turn presents his family with an enormous check. In many ways, he thinks of this quote as for Biff, the son he wronged in so many ways.
Characters-
Willy Loman is completely consumed with the past, primarily because he could never come to terms with the exact time when his happy family broke apart irreparably. From the moment his prodigal son discovered Willy’s affair with another woman, the bright and successful future they were all hoping for vanished. At the time during which the play is written—the days before Willy’s “sacrificial” suicide—Willy has constant flashbacks to the time before that fateful event, his way of reconciling the past with the present, which he never truly does. He is unkind to his wife and in many ways, crippled by the guilt he feels for singlehandedly throwing both his own life and those of his sons off track with his actions in the past. When things don’t appear to be able to improve in the lives of his family, Willy decides that to commit suicide and allow his family to collect the life insurance that would come of it is the only viable option.
Biff
Loman is a product of broken dreams, and his outlook on
life is completely different compared to that of his father, Willy’s. He
believes that it is essential to accept one’s lot in life without question; he
doesn’t believe himself able to achieve success, so he never will. In
comparison, Willy always had hope and a desire for success, even when he no
longer had reason to. Before he found out about his father’s affair, Biff had a
considerably bright future playing football and making his beloved father
proud. He allowed his discovery to destroy every bit of promise he had in him;
it caused him to give up on life.
Happy
Loman is Biff’s brother. His name is appropriately fitting
to his character; he is for all intents and purposes a happy person, without
much concern for anything in life. Many of his traits resemble those of his
father; he likes women, he thinks himself as more important than he really is,
and he has empty and false ambitions similar to Willy’s.
Linda
Loman is
Willy’s wife. She is revered by her sons, especially Biff, and treated
considerably unfairly by her husband. She is wise and sees all that is going on
with Willy and with her children, yet neglects to do anything about it. A
perfect example of the recurring theme of “Too little too late” in the play,
when she discovers evidence of Willy’s desire to kill himself, she does nothing
about it, not wishing to diminish his pride.
Ben
Loman is Willy’s older and much more successful brother.
One of Willy’s deepest regrets in life is not having gone into business with
Ben, who made it big mining in Africa. Ben is a rugged character who represents
the value of a self-made man.
Charley
is Willy’s only friend, though their relationship is fairly business-casual in
nature. Willy borrows money to pay off his various household expenses every
week from Charley, and declines him when he offers him a job at his company. He
is a bit of a foil for Willy in that he is successful and happy in his life.
Bernard
is Charley’s son, a successful and driven young man the same age as Biff. His
life serves as an exact foil to Biff’s for he actually made something of
himself and has a healthy relationship with his father.
Harold
is
Willy’s boss and shares uncomfortable similarities with Willy as a younger man.
Inferred from the recordings on his phonograph, Harold is not incredibly nice
to his wife, thinks very highly of his son, and is very involved with his job. He
ends up firing Willy and figuratively ends his life, pushing him to suicide.
The
Woman is the one Willy had his affair with; she is part of
the reason Biff gave up on existence.
Quotes:
“Yes!
Yes. Coming! It’s very smart, you realize that, don’t you sweetheart? Even Ben
sees it. I gotta go, baby. Bye! Bye! Imagine? When the mail comes he’ll be
ahead of Bernard again.” When Willy says this, he has just
decided on suicide as the only alternative to saving his family. The money they
will receive will be more than enough for them to live comfortably. In reality,
though, he is really only doing this for Biff, his one loose end in the world.
With this money, he hopes to win back his affection. (pg. 108)
"Terrific. Terrific job, boys. Good work, Biff." (pg. 17)
This quote displays Willy's affinity for nondescript adjectives such as "terrific" and "remarkable" and also his reverence of Biff. He cannot commend both of his boys equally; Biff is forever the golden child, though he never amounts to anything.
"Terrific. Terrific job, boys. Good work, Biff." (pg. 17)
This quote displays Willy's affinity for nondescript adjectives such as "terrific" and "remarkable" and also his reverence of Biff. He cannot commend both of his boys equally; Biff is forever the golden child, though he never amounts to anything.
Motifs-
Lying
Exhaustion
Disconnection from reality
Dreams
Denial
Individualism
Loss of self-worth
Broken promises
Inability to let go of the past
Narrative Voice:
Arthur Miller was a Jewish man married to a Christian woman at the time that he wrote DoS, and several religious themes such as sin and prodigal sons come to light in the play. Otherwise, the play simply serves to expose broken family values brought about by personal failures and shortcomings that are subject to any person.
Sunday, November 10, 2013
Close Reading Analysis #3
Slate columnist L.V Anderson's article detailing a Saskatchewan restaurant's decision to call one of its burgers the "Crack Pepper Burger" in an obvious jab at Rob Ford, the mayor of Toronto, whose personal crack problem has grown in media popularity over the past few weeks. In the article, Anderson uses advanced diction, dual-meaning language, and conversational syntax in order to express the humor intended in the message of the story itself.
The author's choice of diction varies
throughout the piece but is marked most obviously through her use of
interspersed "big words" within fairly simple sentences. In her introduction
to the subject of the article, Anderson writes "creating stunt burgers—beef patties surrounded by
deep-fried Twinkies, for instance—is a hackneyed affront to everything a burger should
be." The use of mock-elevated diction, as seen with her use of the phrase
"hackneyed affront" provides a bit of tongue-in-cheek humoring
regarding the simultaneously offensive and ridiculous topic at hand.
(Which is, of course, the mayor's drug addiction)
Language serves as the main vector
through which Anderson's humor is expressed. Using words and phrases that have
double meaning, a bit of authorial humor is tacked on to the situational humor
already present in the events of the story itself. When she writes "but
Rob Ford’s “tribute hamburger,” as Grub Street called
it, is not nearly as tasteless as it sounds," and by following that up
with a comment on the dual meaning of the word tasteless, Anderson uses the
presence of homonyms in our language (Tasteless: classless and tasteless;
without taste in a literal sense) to further extend the humor of her
article.
Lastly, Anderson's decision to write her
article using conversational syntax provides a more relateable feel on the
reader's behalf that allows the humorous nature of the story to be better put
across. Using informal punctuation such as exclamation points-- "It
alludes to the fact that Rob Ford actually, indisputably smoked crack!"
and parenthetical asides such as "(“Tasteless” in the sense of
“offensive,” that is; not living in or near Regina, Saskatchewan, I can’t vouch
for how delicious it is.)", the tone of the article is kept light-hearted
and sufficiently respectful while detailing such a darkly funny and slightly
serious topic. This also works to provide a juxtaposition of the two situations
present in the article; the grave matter of the mayor's crack problem and the
hilarious one of the restaurant's decision to make fun of it.
Sunday, October 27, 2013
Super Cool Response to Course Material 2.0
They say the
point of literature is to make one feel; if a novel or play has done that, has
really tapped into the subconscious of a reader, really played into his or her
emotions, said work has done well. While I agree with this, in some ways it
seems that DOS has done this too well.
The feelings that the play invokes are dark and unsettling. They reach deep
down into the pit of our souls and bring about a sense of grief and loss as we
observe the characters do what they can with the unfortunate lot in life they
were given.
In class, we
debated whether or not DOS truly falls under the category of a “tragic play”
according to the textbook definition of said term. According to the various supplementary
texts we received on the issue, it seems to me that a true tragedy in
literature recounts someone of high societal stature’s fall from grace. While
colloquially we use the word “tragic” to describe any sad or unfortunate event,
this is not the same when describing tragedy in theatre.
In this case,
the answer is no: DOS is not a true “tragedy” as Willy Lowman was never of especially
high nobility within his world and therefore had no fall from grace to speak
of; he was simply a dreamer who allowed his dreams to eventually lead him to a
sad, unnecessary death. However, after reading Miller’s essay on Tragedy and the Common Man, I think an
entirely new context can be added to the reading of DOS.
It is obvious
that Miller, knowing full well the definition of “tragedy”, set about to
redefine the concept in the context of his own play. This seems perfectly reasonable to me; if a man can create an entirely new world with his words, why
can’t he create his own definition of the ones used? To Miller, the story of
Willy Lowman is a new type of tragedy; it is that of the common man. He had no
fall to speak of, no title to lose; this in itself made him a tragic figure.
Willy’s abundance of dreams and lack of success it led to his own personal
demise in a way that can only be described as a tragedy, even if only in a
modern sense.
We also analyzed
several poems over the past few weeks, two of which being My Father’s Song by Simon Ortiz and Promises Like Piecrusts by Christina Rossetti. As for Ortiz’s poem,
the amount of meaning we managed to analyze from his basic words was astounding
and I think we are all on our way to becoming masters of literature. Promises Like Piecrusts, however, meant
a bit more to me personally. I thought that the poem was extremely deep in the
idea it conveyed and the more and more our class discussed it the more themes
appeared. I thought that our analysis was an in-depth one, but also that the
poem itself had much to offer with its commentary on love, social morays, and
prudence.
As we continue our
discussions on DOS and of the other various literary works read in class, I
look forward to further developing my critical thinking skills and capabilities
when it comes to in-depth analysis of texts.
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Open Prompt #2- Response to Student Responses (AKA Response-ception)
“The prompt for Question 3, the “open” question,
began by noting that many writers use a country setting to establish values
within a work of literature and illustrated that proposition by pointing out
that the country may be a place of virtue and peace or one of primitivism and
ignorance. Students were then asked to choose a novel or play in which such a
country setting plays a significant role and write an essay in which they
analyzed how the country setting functions in the work as a whole.”
Essay 1-
The language in the
first essay is extremely stiff and lacks the dynamic necessary to make writing
enjoyable to read. Many of the points the writer makes are very general and not
analytical enough to warrant recognition for being good observations. The
writer’s claims about Jane Austen’s Persuasion
are not fully formed; they lack a solid connection between the text and the
question. Many of these within the essay are weak or poorly phrased. Apparently,
however, I do not appear to share the same critical thinking skills as the graders
of the AP Literature essays, because this essay got an 8. Upon further
reflection, though the essay’s organization appeared to be a bit too structured
and uncreative, it did clearly define the specific values that the country
supplied the novel’s main character, and thus addresses the question far more
than either of the other essays managed to. It also presents ample evidence to support its claims, and though the writing is not stellar to my overly-critical eyes, the author obviously kept the prompt in mind for the duration of the essay, which contributed to the high score received.
Essay 2-
This essay is far too
short and wordy to have gotten enough points across to get too many points. That
is to say, though sometimes length does not sacrifice content, it did in this
case. The author also focused too much on the aspect of humor within The Importance of Being Earnest as
opposed to staying true to the question of country values within the play. The
essay closes with the author restating its position, saying that The Importance of Being Earnest is “a
play of trivial humor” which is not entirely relevant to the question. Though
the author does relate the countryside to the play’s comedy, the connection
lacks enough evidence to back up the claims made. The question of the prompt
was pertaining to specific values associated with the “country” as a whole, not
just how the setting served as a plot device to move the story along. The
author also makes several grammar and diction mistakes, an example of which
being the misuse of the word “discriminate” when what was meant to be said was
most likely “distinguish.”
Essay 3-
The
final essay distinctly lacks a scholarly tone and syntax and instead writes as
if in conversation, distracting the reader from the point of the essay.
Sentences are fragmented and many of the claims made are not described fully in
order to relate back to the country setting of Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying. The writing as a whole does not have much
complexity. Many of the sentences start with the same words, and their
structures do not vary. In trying to get the point across that the South is responsible
for many of the character actions within the novel, the author fails to explain
how and why such values exist in the “countryside” there. This distinctly
misses the point of the question and thus renders the essay a critique on the
novel’s characters based on their being from the Southern part of the U.S.
Though the evidence from the text is strong for the author’s claims on the
qualities of the characters, the fact that it does not relate these qualities
strongly enough to the country itself and to the values that are thus present
there gave it a rather low score.
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
Summary and Analysis- The American Dream
The
Not-So-Basic Theme
The
American Dream warns that the current generation is quickly losing touch with
the older, more admirable American values and is instead replacing them with a
cultural upholding of materialism and the overall desire to reach an
unsubstantial, elusive sense of ‘satisfaction’ and thus losing touch with what
really matters, or used to matter.
A strong social commentary, The American Dream provides insight into the mind of author Edward Albee and his perceptions on what the popular culture of the time blatantly lacked in values.
A multitude of symbols are present in the play in order to convey this idea. Mommy and Daddy adopt a "bumble", a malapropism of the word "bundle". They eventually murder this child in every sense of the word over the course of their attempts to knock it down and mold it into something that will give them satisfaction, They remain unfazed by the death of their child and soon after simply call the adoption agency and ask for another so they may get their money's worth.
Daddy's sex change embodies the increasing fragility of traditional societal gender roles in the household and out. He is now a woman, dominated by a woman, unable to experience satisfaction like a man or defend himself against his wife. It is repeated multiple times that Daddy has "definite qualms" about his situation, but he is unable to find a voice for these qualms as he no longer has the power to do so.
Mommy's story about the hat incident displays the absurd, irrational nature of the times along with the concept of consumerism. Mommy goes out and buys a hat, returns it, then buys it again all in the name of getting the right color -beige or cream- and thus, satisfaction. Nothing is enough for any of the characters of the play; the hat is not enough for Mommy, the bumble is not enough for Mommy and Daddy, and no one thinks that Grandma's ideas are enough to warrant attention. At the rate the characters, and a parallel sense the American culture, are going, they will soon forget all of the "real" American values and begin to uphold instead those of ignorance and immorality.
As depressing as the claims of the play appear, the ending provides readers with a shred of hope. When Grandma leaves the characters onstage and enters the audience, she is symbolically interacting with the members of the culture about which Albee writes, hinting to them that there is still time to change and maintain the honor and morality that those of her generation exulted.
The setting
of the play is a simple living room set with two chairs angled toward one
another and facing the audience. This invokes a sense of familiarity, as it is
obviously representative of the typical American household. Such simple recognition
allows viewers/readers of the play to connect with it immediately.
The plot
moves in a series of circles in order to get to the end point. In the
beginning, Mommy and Daddy are waiting for someone to come to their home and
bring them something that is supposedly of large importance but that they cannot
remember the details of. Grandma lives with them and is often the sardonic,
realist voice amidst their depthless conversation and foolish actions.
Eventually, Grandma is replaced in the household with the Young Man, who turns
out to be just the thing that Daddy and Mommy were looking for; a malleable shell
of a person without true feelings or needs. It is implied that Grandma is not
gone forever, however. At the end of the play, she steps out into the audience
and addresses them directly.
Mommy
is
the head of the household and can be most accurately described as aggressive and
superficial. She dominates over Daddy in a twisted role-reversal that seems to
contradict the popular idea of the American household at the time. Her emotions
fickle and fleeting, and she is selfishly on the constant search for ‘satisfaction’,
most often in a material sense. She feels validated by money and things, with
no honor for integrity or morality.
Daddy
lacks
a backbone and a well-defined sense of masculinity. It is implied that he
underwent a sex change operation recently to the play’s beginning, as he still
has the stitches from the procedure. He doesn’t appear completely comfortable
with this, yet never finds the words to say so to anyone else. He is still obviously
straight, but his sexual reactions are now completely that of a woman. Compared
to Mommy, Daddy is easily manipulated and complacent.
Grandma
is the exception to it all. She has a dynamic character and deep understanding
of the people she is with that allows her to act in just the right way in every
situation. To Mommy and Daddy she plays the role of the bitter old woman who is
no longer of any value, but to the Young Man and Mrs. Barker, she provides
guidance and a silent wisdom that the other characters never see of her. It is
in this way that she exists both inside and out of the ridiculous reality in
which the play is set. She can be part of it, but also see completely though
it.
Mrs.
Barker is a lesser character but is nonetheless of great
importance. She is a professional woman,
a phrase that could have multiple meanings. She is ultimately responsible—with
the help of Grandma— for bringing a new “child” to Mommy and Daddy, which
connects with the concept of professional womanhood in a literal sense.
The
Young Man is both a replacement and a replica of the previous
bumble that Mommy and Daddy murdered in their attempt to morph him into
something cohesive with their values. He is essentially the old bumble
revamped, complete with a lack of feelings and depth that Mommy and Daddy see
as desirable in people.
To consider Albee himself in the context of his play
brings about an entirely new set of questions. The time period in which he was
raised, his family life, and his sexuality all can be connected in one way or another
to certain aspects of The American Dream. However, it is much more
reasonable to analyze the play in a formalist sense, and disconnect from any
assumptions about the author. To dissect his style as an author, along with the
ties his writing style has to the Theatre of the Absurd, creates an important context
to the play.
Quotes
Grandma: I don’t know if that’s what I meant or not.
It’s certainly what I thought I meant. (Pg. 81)
This statement reflects the general explanation
behind the majority of the actions of the characters in The American Dream. They do not actually know what they want or
mean, just what they think they do, which leads to uncertainty and a lack of reliability
on all parts.
Daddy: That’s the way things are these days; you
just can’t get satisfaction; you just try. (Pg. 61)
Satisfaction is a major motif of the play; the
characters are always searching for it, losing it, and then searching for it
some more. It is a fleeting, intangible thing that the majority of the
characters can never seem to find. Mommy claims to be able to find
satisfaction; she claims so outright and then tells Daddy that he cannot. This
is another reference to Daddy’s lost sexuality along with his altogether
inferiority to her.
The Young Man: I’ll do almost anything for money.
(Pg. 109)
This new generation, believing in the new American
Dream, puts a high value on materialism and money. As Grandma welcomes the
Young Man in, who stands for this very dream, we see that he also subscribes to
this notion. He is completely lacking in feeling and other desires, and only
really needs money to get on in life. It is a superficial value that Albee
places upon this new generation that lacks fundamental, genuine values.
Motifs-
·
Degradation of traditional family
values/gender roles
·
Value placed on materialism and money
·
Fleeting satisfaction
·
Childlike behavior in adults
·
Transition of values from one generation
to the next
·
Power struggle
·
Lack of honor
Narrative Voice-
Albee takes cues from the Theatre of the Absurd in
his writing. His dialogue is typically cyclical and senseless in nature and
conclusions are rarely drawn. Rather than invoking a lack of meaning, however,
Albee instead places many subtle social commentaries in the actions of his
characters. Frustrated with the prevalent lack of depth and values in the
younger generation of his time, Albee zeros in on their faults in order to
expose the tragic superficiality the culture he perceived.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)