Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response to Course Material #1

Most recently during this past month or so of school, we read our first work of literature of the year: The American Dream, written by Edward Albee. This play represents a large amount of different concepts, starting with existentialism and an overall negative outlook on life. Out of all the claims of existentialism, the work most obviously focuses on two specific ideas, which are that of absurdity and the irrational, inexplicable nature of certain aspects of life. A certain genre of theatre—called the theatre of the absurd— contains literature that embraces these ideas. Typically, said plays are cyclical in their plots and contain issues that never get resolved and characters that seldom grow.
The American Dream, though often characterized as part of the absurdist theatre, contains numerous elements that disqualify it from being labeled as such. The play is fraught with underlying commentary and allusions to the culture of the 1960’s. In essence, the situations the characters face along with their reactions to them are Albee’s way of satirizing what he saw as “wrong” with America during that time. Because of this depth to the story, it cannot very well be considered “absurdist” as it is not absurd or useless at all; it speaks volumes on the characteristics of humans and of the culture they have created.
Before that, we learned about close reading and the various levels of meaning that can be derived from observing and analyzing certain aspects of literature. Using annotation to mark our findings, we paid attention to mechanical parts of writing—syntax, diction, language, etc— and decided what they meant for the purpose of reading comprehension. This helps to broaden a reader’s understanding of a piece beyond simple themes and what is taken from a thoughtless processing an author’s words.
I think that the various practice we've gotten analyzing student responses to AP prompts also helped with furthering our comprehension as to what is to be expected of us on the exam itself. Over time we will come to know full well what will earn us a 9 on our essays and what will not.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt Blog no. 1

An Analysis of the 2008 Student Answer Responses of the use of literary devices in the passage from Anita Desai's novel Fasting, Feasting. 

Student #1's essay does an overall adequate job at analyzing the excerpt given, but has a fairly week opening sentence. It begins with the discussion of Desai's use of a "variety of techiniques", a statement that could well have been better dictated. The thesis of the essay, however, is clear and easy to follow as it foreshadows the essay's specific topics including "alternating diction, speech, and point of view". The essay falters a bit on its use of descriptive words and phrases. For example, rather than referring to the diction as "matter-of-fact type", the student would have done well to choose a more concise adjective. As the essay wears on, it is obvious that the student understands what the question is asking and consistently makes good connections between the text and the the author's intent. The student's use of quotes to support the essay's positions is ample, but doesn't distract from the voice of the student itself. It is quite apparent that the student is well-versed in the devices used in literature as it describes the use of third person limited/omniscient narrative and rhetorical questions within the text. From here the students makes an observation of the use of irony in the passage to create an unsettled mood for the main character as he interacts with his new surroundings. The closing paragraph effectively restates the point of the essay and serves as a good closure for the work itself. 

Student #2's essay begins nicely with a detailed topic sentence that sets the tone and message of the essay. Some of the word choice reflects the student's desire to sound overly intelligent. The use of words such as "fostered", "heightened", and "apprehensive" make the voice of the essay sound bulky and overstated, especially when such words have much simpler synonyms that would be a better fit to the text. It appears that the first paragraph lacks a concrete thesis statement. The student obviously has good ideas regarding the literary devices used in the excerpt but continues to overdo the descriptions used in the defense of its ideas. Many of the sentences begin with the word "He" or "The", and the lack of variation creates a dull tone that is not entirely engaging. Aside from some of the mechanical and tonal issues, the essay itself makes accurate connections to the excerpt given and properly addresses all parts of the prompt. The lack of conclusion at the end of the essay causes it to end rather abruptly without a final restatement of ideas and surely caused graders to take off a few points from its grade.

Student #3's essay uses overly simple language and diction that makes the point of the essay vague and difficult to fully understand from the very beginning. The majority of the sentences begin with "The" or "He", both of with are uninteresting openers and must be switched up every once in a while to create a better tone to the essay. Rather than defending an opinion on the literary devices used in the excerpt with relevant information, it appears that student is simply dictating information to the reader in a fashion that is not engaging. Many of the positions the student takes are obvious from the reading and are in turn not conclusions based on information, but rather restatements of what are likely sections from the excerpt. The student's thoughts appear undeveloped and quite basic in the way they are structured and presented throughout the paragraphs. In addition, the student only discusses two devices of literature, narration and speech, and provides little indication as to which one it is referring to at a given point in the essay. Overall, the work itself was vague and did not come to the proper conclusion that the prompt desired from students.  

Sunday, September 15, 2013

He's Not Holden- An Analysis of Rosenbaum's Style

In Slate article He’s Not Holden (link below), author Ron Rosenbaum laments the tendency of people to attribute the thoughts and ideas of characters to the authors that created them. In his work, Rosenbaum goes in-depth about this issue, citing the recent film and book Salinger to make his case. Rosenbaum use of dynamic language, quality syntax, and varying diction allows him to get his point across in a fashion that makes his article easily comprehensible yet well-informed.
The language in which Rosenbaum writes his article is one that conveys both his expansive knowledge on the subject of Salinger and his keen sense of humor. It makes the reading both easy to comprehend and also to respect, as it is apparent that Rosenbaum is a very educated man. Parts of the piece are written quite informally, as if they are to be spoken to a friend or colleague. When Rosenbaum writes “Aha, the authors virtually high five each other: proof!” the effect of this conversational language on the reader is positive in that it lends a bit of excitement to the informative piece. Rosenbaum’s opener, “I didn’t want to write this piece. I’ve got Salinger fatigue, and I bet you do too” (Rosenbaum) for example, is quite a personable start for a piece that is supposed to be educational, but the author’s use of this technique allows the reader to become more engaged an interested with the work.
Rosenbaum’s use of syntax allows his work to be read quite easily, even enjoyably, and makes no room for possible comprehension errors. He is careful not to make his work seem dry or stuffy; everything about the structure of the article is fast-paced and interesting. No two sentences follow the exact same pattern, which ensures that those reading the piece will remain interested. Much of the syntax reads like a conversation, or at the very least an informal commentary. For example, Rosenbaum’s phrase “And a great relief! It almost sounds as if Salinger found a way to escape the Glass family trap (the trapped family Glass?) by writing explicitly about his wartime experiences” (Rosenbaum) uses very dynamic and unusual punctuation, such as exclamation points and parentheses. This makes the reading much more appealing to the human eye and mind, thus holding an observer’s intrigue.  

He’s Not Holden’s diction is quite scholarly in that very uncommon and high-brow words are used fairly often. Though the article itself is perfectly simple to understand, it is entirely possible for a reader to get caught up on a word or two. Rosenbaum is undeniably an educated, scholarly man; he chooses to use words such as “perpetuates”, “fundamental”, and “recrudescence”, all of which have much simpler synonyms. This allows the article to sound much more intellectual in reading. A good portion of his phrases, such as “[he] stuffed his later prose with undigested mystical didactism” (Rosenbaum) use this elevated diction as well. The article is altogether extremely informed and lively in its nature and in the way it is perceived by a reader. 

A link to the original article-
http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/the_spectator/2013/09/interpreting_catcher_in_the_rye_the_one_big_mistake_people_make.html