Sunday, December 8, 2013

Close Reading #I stopped counting


A hilarious narrative of a childhood faux-pas, Elizabeth Weingarten's article about the time she, a young Jewish girl, believed she had revealed the big secret of Santa's inexistence to a fellow 3rd grade classmate. The incident apparently haunted her into her adult life, where she finally contacted the girl whose life she believed to have ruined through her callous disclosure of the truth. Weingarten's article uses colorful imagery, dynamic syntax, and educated language and diction to convey a message of humor to readers. 
The point of Weingarten's piece was to tell a story and, as is crucial to good storytelling, contained vivid imagery. The author opens her retelling of the event with a description of its setting: "During one December art class, groups gathered around long, paint-splattered tables, coloring with broken crayons and chewed markers". This creates a playful, childish mood and paints a picture that just about everyone can relate to their youth in school. Other sections convey the message through humorous imagery. As the author laments her actions, she writes “Does [the girl] think of me each year by the Christmas tree, her eggnog made bitter by the memory of the day I took an axe to her childish sense of awe and wonder?” Sentences like these add imagination and comical mental imagery that work to make the article more engaging.
            The dynamic syntax of the article works namely to humorous ends, often leading into certain ‘punch lines’ in various structures. One of these methods involves a colon, and example of which being “Each year, around Christmas, I recall the events of that afternoon and wonder: Did my gaffe kill part of her hopeful, glittering soul?” The simple lead to the sentences sets up a comical end with the colon that adds to the overall humor of the piece. Another method the author uses is indenting certain sentences in order to add a subtle emphasis to the humor intended at that specific part of the article:

“What, exactly, was the appalling crime of these two women? They both denied the existence of Santa Claus. Now, they’re paying for it.
I feel their pain.”
This ensures that a reader’s eye takes in the passage in a specific way, which in turn emphasizes humor.
The language of the piece exemplifies something that is quite common with the writer’s at Slate. Though the articles are simplistic stylistically, the word choice and overall tone of the pieces are highly educated and work to make reading them pleasing to the mind to read. When talking about what it was like to know about the inexistence of Santa, Weingarten says she felt “deliciously superior”, an unusual term that stands out in the writing and catches a reader’s attention. One sentence in particular stands out as having specifically quality diction and overall language: “But even the occasional verbal slip-up does little to erode a kid’s ironclad belief.” Strong words like ‘erode’ and ‘ironclad’ paired with the simple syntax of the sentence make it interesting to read and add to the enjoyable nature of the article. 
The writing style used in Weingarten's article allowed it to come off as simple, sweet, and funny. The author's use of varied syntax, vivid imagery and professional language and diction all worked to engage the reader and keep the article entertaining. 

3 comments:

  1. Hi Bella,
    I really enjoyed reading your post, the article sounds interesting and funny. You did a good job of giving a quick summary of the article without having that as the focus of your blog post. I know I accidentally end up summarizing more than necessary sometimes in my posts. I think that you might want to avoid using first person in your close readings because they are supposed to be in essay format and we typically don’t use first person then. You do a good job of using quotes and explaining them. I think that having a conclusion to wrap everything up would make your close reading stronger. I noticed too that most of Slate’s writers have a simple writing style but the diction is typically elevated. Overall though, great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bella,
    Once again you’ve done a great job dissecting the article you chose and showing how the different elements come together. Your thesis was great though the phrase “educated language” threw me for a minute, I wasn’t sure if you were talking about the element of language (figurative language) or that the word choice was strong. When I got to that paragraph it I got it, so that was probably just a misunderstanding on my part. The examples you used in all three of your body paragraphs were good, though I think a few fell on the long side (I also have a tendency to use long quotes so I understand this probably too well). This was a well thought out post and I don’t have much to criticize. Besides the lengths of a few quotes the only other thing I really have to say is that I wish you had thrown in a few more examples for each. Really great post Bella.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear Bella,
    Ooh Susheela is right. You cant talk about your personal reactions, but must write from the objective-seeming institutional perspective of "the essayist." This article was really funny, and you picked good things to discuss. Great use of examples from the text!

    The only thing I'm not sure about is how you explained the use of spacing and indenting to make the reader follow the words in a particular manner. I'm referring to the example ending with "I feel their pain." I don't think that structure directly conveys humor like you suggest. I think it conveys drama or suspense. It's the fact that such a dark and dramatic structure is emphasizing a truly trivial issue that creates the comedy. Do you know what I mean? The structure is quite serious, but the topic is lighthearted, and it's that sort of juxtaposition that makes it funny.

    That's just how I thought of it. Either way. Awesome article, great analysis. Good job!

    ReplyDelete