Sunday, October 27, 2013

Super Cool Response to Course Material 2.0



They say the point of literature is to make one feel; if a novel or play has done that, has really tapped into the subconscious of a reader, really played into his or her emotions, said work has done well. While I agree with this, in some ways it seems that DOS has done this too well. The feelings that the play invokes are dark and unsettling. They reach deep down into the pit of our souls and bring about a sense of grief and loss as we observe the characters do what they can with the unfortunate lot in life they were given.
In class, we debated whether or not DOS truly falls under the category of a “tragic play” according to the textbook definition of said term. According to the various supplementary texts we received on the issue, it seems to me that a true tragedy in literature recounts someone of high societal stature’s fall from grace. While colloquially we use the word “tragic” to describe any sad or unfortunate event, this is not the same when describing tragedy in theatre.
In this case, the answer is no: DOS is not a true “tragedy” as Willy Lowman was never of especially high nobility within his world and therefore had no fall from grace to speak of; he was simply a dreamer who allowed his dreams to eventually lead him to a sad, unnecessary death. However, after reading Miller’s essay on Tragedy and the Common Man, I think an entirely new context can be added to the reading of DOS.
It is obvious that Miller, knowing full well the definition of “tragedy”, set about to redefine the concept in the context of his own play. This seems perfectly reasonable to me; if a man can create an entirely new world with his words, why can’t he create his own definition of the ones used? To Miller, the story of Willy Lowman is a new type of tragedy; it is that of the common man. He had no fall to speak of, no title to lose; this in itself made him a tragic figure. Willy’s abundance of dreams and lack of success it led to his own personal demise in a way that can only be described as a tragedy, even if only in a modern sense.
We also analyzed several poems over the past few weeks, two of which being My Father’s Song by Simon Ortiz and Promises Like Piecrusts by Christina Rossetti. As for Ortiz’s poem, the amount of meaning we managed to analyze from his basic words was astounding and I think we are all on our way to becoming masters of literature. Promises Like Piecrusts, however, meant a bit more to me personally. I thought that the poem was extremely deep in the idea it conveyed and the more and more our class discussed it the more themes appeared. I thought that our analysis was an in-depth one, but also that the poem itself had much to offer with its commentary on love, social morays, and prudence.
As we continue our discussions on DOS and of the other various literary works read in class, I look forward to further developing my critical thinking skills and capabilities when it comes to in-depth analysis of texts.

4 comments:

  1. The only thing of real significance that you missed here is what we learned about multiple choice--otherwise this is quite thorough. I would like to see a bit more synthesis of material across the course and connecting of the material to experiences (academic and otherwise) from outside of this course, though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bella,
    Like Ms. Holmes mentioned you commented on mostly everything we have learned and talked about recently. You did forget about the multiple choice stuff we learned about but I myself forgot a few things as well since it is hard to remember everything we do everyday. So I would say this is a pretty well written response. I think you did a great job of not just summarizing but also actually responding to the material. Maybe like Mr. Holmes mentioned just try and connect the material to other experiences. Overall, this covered most all the information and is very detailed! Have you enjoyed the class and material so far? I know I certainly have learned a lot and am excited to learn even more!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella,
    Like you, I do not believe that "Death of a Salesman" is a tragedy in the "traditional" sense. It is in no way on the level of something like "Macbeth" or "Hamlet" where a nobleman falls from his high place and there's a ghost and a bloodbath at the end and etc., etc., but I do believe Miller intended it to be tragic, though not in that sense. I'm pretty sure many others share this same view, but it's good to differentiate between the two kinds of tragedy, as the next play we're reading is "Hamlet", basically the benchmark for all tragedies to follow. And do you believe that the critic of DOS who railed against its "non-literariness" (I can't remember his name) was too harsh on the book? I feel that DOS has its flaws, but that it is still "literature" and not below the level of other works.

    About the poetry we've been reading, you speak of "deeper" meanings that you though could be found in "Promises Like Pie-Crusts." I was not especially enthused by that poem, finding it not poorly-written but simple, and I didn't take as much from it as perhaps I could've. I'd like to hear your differing interpretations on this poem, as you could reveal to me some earth-shattering point that could rock the very foundation of my existence. After all, that's what literature's supposed to do.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bella,
    I thought this was a pretty good summary of what we’ve done in class. I especially enjoyed your analysis of how Death of a Salesman could be considered a tragedy, though not in the traditional sense. Do you think that there really can be a standing definition of tragedy as times and culture are always changing? When you said “[Willy] had no fall to speak of, no title to lose; this in itself made him a tragic figure” was particularly interesting to me. I agree that Willy had no real title to lose, but I think it could be argued that he did have a fall. In my opinion, Willy’s “fall” could be when Biff caught him in his affair, as that seems to be when many of his problems begin (including the riff the forms between him and his son). I thought your mentioning of the work we’ve been doing with poetry was also really good. Good analysis Bella!

    ReplyDelete