Sunday, November 10, 2013

Close Reading Analysis #3


Slate columnist L.V Anderson's article detailing a Saskatchewan restaurant's decision to call one of its burgers the "Crack Pepper Burger" in an obvious jab at Rob Ford, the mayor of Toronto, whose personal crack problem has grown in media popularity over the past few weeks. In the article, Anderson uses advanced diction, dual-meaning language, and conversational syntax in order to express the humor intended in the message of the story itself.
The author's choice of diction varies throughout the piece but is marked most obviously through her use of interspersed "big words" within fairly simple sentences. In her introduction to the subject of the article, Anderson writes "creating stunt burgers—beef patties surrounded by deep-fried Twinkies, for instance—is a hackneyed affront to everything a burger should be." The use of mock-elevated diction, as seen with her use of the phrase "hackneyed affront" provides a bit of tongue-in-cheek humoring regarding the simultaneously offensive and ridiculous topic at hand. (Which is, of course, the mayor's drug addiction)
Language serves as the main vector through which Anderson's humor is expressed. Using words and phrases that have double meaning, a bit of authorial humor is tacked on to the situational humor already present in the events of the story itself. When she writes "but Rob Ford’s “tribute hamburger,” as Grub Street called it, is not nearly as tasteless as it sounds," and by following that up with a comment on the dual meaning of the word tasteless, Anderson uses the presence of homonyms in our language (Tasteless: classless and tasteless; without taste in a literal sense) to further extend the humor of her article. 


Lastly, Anderson's decision to write her article using conversational syntax provides a more relateable feel on the reader's behalf that allows the humorous nature of the story to be better put across. Using informal punctuation such as exclamation points-- "It alludes to the fact that Rob Ford actually, indisputably smoked crack!" and parenthetical asides such as "(“Tasteless” in the sense of “offensive,” that is; not living in or near Regina, Saskatchewan, I can’t vouch for how delicious it is.)", the tone of the article is kept light-hearted and sufficiently respectful while detailing such a darkly funny and slightly serious topic. This also works to provide a juxtaposition of the two situations present in the article; the grave matter of the mayor's crack problem and the hilarious one of the restaurant's decision to make fun of it. 

3 comments:

  1. Bella,
    Interesting article. And in no way does this mean that I'm knocking your choice in finding articles. NOOO! I find that I actually must agree with you in this post of yours. As I read through this article I felt far from overwhelmed. The sentence structuring was indeed self-explanatory. I didn't need to reread, but I admit I was caught by the power of Anderson's techniques and felt obligated to reread this brief editorial of hers. Her use of diction is easily recognizable from the addition of "addictive" to "edible", I'm more than certain that many people should be able to pick up what she's writing. You seem to grasp her message clearly and your intellect shows when you identify "tasteless" as also being "classless." Any other words you want to include when you mention Anderson's varying use of diction? To add more support, of course. Great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Bella,
    As Ludia mentioned, this is an interesting article to choose. I normally do not read through the articles but I was so intrigued by this one that I decided too! And might I add that you did a great job on this close reading!! I totally agree that the author used advanced diction, dual-meaning language and controversial diction. It is impressive that you were able to spot all these things right away too! You also did a really nice job of adding quotes from the article to support your statements. Overall, nothing I can think of that could make your essay better except for maybe adding more description in your explanations. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella,
    Great job on your close reading. I, too, found this article very fascinating, a funny choice. You had a great response format: an intro and three strong and developed body paragraphs. I was most impressed with your identification of the role "language" played in this article.Usually people respond with the typical Imagery diction syntax, however, you really went above and beyond here. Impressive. You have some great evidence to back up your claims, a couple more would make this response top notch! I don't have much else to say as far as critiques go, so good work!!

    ReplyDelete