Tragic Figures as Instruments for the Suffering of Others
Open Prompt Question 3, 2003
Essay #1
The first essay did well with regard to pulling ample amounts of textual evidence from The Great Gatsby and making connections between the prompt and the novel. However, the student had quite a few problems with sticking to one tense and in identifying pronouns clearly in the writing. It also misused several words, significantly so when it claimed that "Gatsby catered to the pandering rich". This sentence doesn't make sense; clearly the writer either wasn't sure what it was trying to say or didn't know what the word 'pander' means. In general, though, the claims made and the ties between "the three scales of tragedy- personal, inter-personal, and societal" were all well supported and clear to any reader familiar or unfamiliar with the novel. The amount of quotes used from The Great Gatsby made me genuinely wonder if the student had the book on hand while completing this essay. I would assume he or she did not, making the whole thing significantly more impressive. Aside from a few grammar and word choice mistakes, I would agree with the College Board's high grade of this essay, as it was certainly better that its successors.
Essay #2
This essay only hurt to read slightly, which is an accomplishment compared to some of the others I've encountered. Its structure wasn't ideal and seemed to have little flow of ideas. Points were disjointed and the writing as a whole lacked several main points that it was trying to convey. Though the essay was supposed to be connecting the character of King Lear to the concept of tragic figures, it trailed off and began discussing other characters in the play, even throwing in a thought about Hamlet at one point. Humorous, yes. Points winning, not on the AP English exam. It was difficult to figure out exactly how and in what ways King Lear was considered tragic. The student discussed his greed and vanity, an excellent trait that leads to a tragic demise, but seemed to only repeat this and didn't really come to new conclusions about his character as the essay went on, stopping to discuss his daughters along the way. A paragraph about what the king represented by having the traits would have likely been useful, in my opinion. The student received a 7 on this essay, which I think was fair. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't professional.
Essay #3
Flimsy to say the least, the third essay was nothing special. It claimed that McMurphey was a good example of a tragic figure, but neglected to acknowledge several undercurrents of the novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It listed several instances when McMurphey's actions affected the other characters negatively, but many of these seemed to serve other reasons in the novel than to display tragedy. Before McMurphey joined the mental ward, many of the patients were leading listless, boring lives, and his arrival changed their lives by adding some excitement. The fact that this argument can be made makes his character not entirely fit for the role of a tragic figure. Aside from this, the student's writing style and syntax was simple without much variation. The essay itself contained a few fragments as well. Collectively, I think the essay's score of a 5 was justified, and it most certainly could have been thought out more.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Bella,
ReplyDeleteGreat job! You caught the small things that I usually miss such as using pronouns incorrectly. It’s interesting though that it was the essay that still received the highest score out of the group. I guess as long as the small mistakes don’t take much away from the overall essay then your good. Then with the second essay, reading your critique on it made me wonder if it was wise to also mention Hamlet when the focus of the essay should have been on King Lear. The third essay seemed to need more work all round. You do a good job of explaining what was wrong with the all three of the essays, it’s clear that you know what you’re doing. Good job again.
Bella,
ReplyDeleteThis post was very well done. You did a great job going in and really analyzing the essays and then articulating your thoughts on them. If I had to guess, I would say that your evaluations are very close to what the AP readers are thinking while reading these essays. Your analysis of Essay 3 was interesting to me because when I read this article back in September, I sort of ripped it apart whereas you didn’t. Personally this essay came across to me as showing how McMurphy was not a tragic hero and brought more joy into the other character’s lives than pain. Did you get this feeling at all or was it just me? Probably the only things I would change would be to put the full prompt on your post and the actual score for the first essay. Both of these are really minor things though; great job.
Dear Bella,
ReplyDeleteSeriously, though. How are these students coming up with all these quotes? Certainly they're essential as the only evidence for an argument, but how are we supposed to remember these lines? And it's poor form to quote something without citations and that's also very difficult in an AP exam. What is going on here?
I'm guessing you have read One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, based on the argument you gave to contradict the student. That's a good thing to consider. I mean, the graders are guaranteed to be exceptionally well read, so if they think your argument is simply wrong, you're probably done for.
As Caitlin and Susheela have said, your analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of each essay are complete and thoughtful, and as long as you apply those observations to your own essays, you're golden. (But of course we were never worried about you to begin with.)