Sunday, October 13, 2013

Close Reading #2


http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/movies/2013/10/romeo_and_juliet_directed_by_downton_abbey_s_julian_fellowes_reviewed.html


Dana Stevens’ review of Hollywood’s newest adaptation of Romeo and Juliet delivers clever commentary on the film itself along with insight as to just how much of the film stayed true to the story of the original star-crossed lovers. The author uses a blend of colorful language, specific diction, and varied syntax to convey an overall positive critique of the film to the reader.
Stevens’ decision to make a subtitle of the article “Don’t Bite Your Thumb at It” provides a smart reference to the play itself while giving advice to the reader: Don’t judge the film too harshly. Using language from the play itself helps to draw the concept of Shakespeare’s original work and the new adaption hundreds of years later together. This paired with the article’s ending statement of “I’m not sure this minor adaptation can count on that kind of word of mouth, but the source material should survive until the next round” (Stevens) work to draw both parallels and distinctions between the two works. Obviously the film is not nearly as excellent in comparison to Shakespeare’s work on stage, but that is regardless not a basis upon which to disregard the quality of the movie version.
In describing the characters onscreen, Stevens has a habit of attributing two concise adjectives to the various actors she is describing. For example, Juliet is “open [and] childlike”, the nurse is “chatty [and] adoring” and the friar is “wry [and] skeptical.” This repetition of phrases allows for a smooth trait-identification for the reader to comprehend and remember. These words are descriptive on their own, and when put into pairs the point that the author is trying to make becomes abundantly clear. Diction in other parts of the article is just as memorable. The author’s use of words such as “impetuousness” “plucky” and “thwarted”—all fairly recognizable, yet intelligent words— make reading the article that much more enjoyable to a reader who enjoys dynamic language and intelligent prose.
Syntax is important in any worthwhile article— it is the thing that keeps a readers interest. After all, if writers write a pieces compatible with the average person’s stream of consciousness, they automatically up the chances of the piece itself being paid attention to. No one wants to read a stuffy work with chopped up sentences. There must be a flow. Stevens does this very well with her use of varied sentence structure and complex punctuation. Devices  such as hyphens, dashes, and side-noted parenthesis all work to make the article sound more like a thought, or perhaps more fittingly, conversational. It sounds like a friend giving another friend a quick opinion on a film. If, granted, said friend were highly skilled in the art of film-critiquing and had a penchant for quirky words.

4 comments:

  1. Bella,
    Wow, you really did a great job picking out the techniques used in your article. While I did not read the article I can tell that you put a lot of work into finding and describing these specific techniques. This is also a very well written essay and actually enjoyable for me to read. If there were one thing you could improve on, it would just be adding more evidence to back up your assertions. While I know everything you are saying is true, if you simply added some more quotes from the article, your essay would be amazing. I really liked how you added specific vocabulary when describing the different techniques the author used as well. It made your essay even more impressive. Overall great job picking out the language, diction, and syntax in this article!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bella,
    While I disagree with a lot of what the article says about the recent remake of Romeo and Juliet, your break down of the article was very good. Your point about Stevens’ concise adjective use was great and I agree that it makes the character traits easy to remember and identify. Also your point about the use of other words (i.e. impetuousness and plucky) do make this article more entertaining to read and give the language a dynamic edge. When discussing the syntax of the article I wish you had given more examples or quoted such examples in your analysis (to me that would have made your point stronger). My one really criticism of your analysis was your paragraph about language. This could just be me, but I was a bit confused while reading this paragraph and a bit unsure as to how it related. I always thought that when discussing the language of a piece we were to be looking more at figurative language used rather than alluding to and using language from the play in the article. Overall I thought this was a good breakdown of Stevens’ article.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella,
    Wonderful job with the analysis here; and I have to say that the aspect I appreciated the most about this post was your concision. You were able to effectively dissect an author's writing style and how she gets across what she wants to in a very small amount of space, something I know I struggle with and I'm sure many others do as well. Though I do have one thing to say to you, and it is merely to add a conclusion to sort of wrap everything up nicely at the end. Maybe not so much for this post but as an exercise in writing, as perfecting how to write conclusions is a skill that will no doubt be used for the rest of our writing careers. I'm sure that you're capable of writing a decent conclusion though, and you don't have to do anything I say anyway.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bella--The first 2/3 of this piece are effective persuasion, but the section on syntax is unconvincing, because it contains a misused term (stream of consciousness) and because it really isn't thoroughly developed with evidence and a thorough warrant.

    ReplyDelete