Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt #2- Response to Student Responses (AKA Response-ception)



“The prompt for Question 3, the “open” question, began by noting that many writers use a country setting to establish values within a work of literature and illustrated that proposition by pointing out that the country may be a place of virtue and peace or one of primitivism and ignorance. Students were then asked to choose a novel or play in which such a country setting plays a significant role and write an essay in which they analyzed how the country setting functions in the work as a whole.”
Essay 1-
The language in the first essay is extremely stiff and lacks the dynamic necessary to make writing enjoyable to read. Many of the points the writer makes are very general and not analytical enough to warrant recognition for being good observations. The writer’s claims about Jane Austen’s Persuasion are not fully formed; they lack a solid connection between the text and the question. Many of these within the essay are weak or poorly phrased. Apparently, however, I do not appear to share the same critical thinking skills as the graders of the AP Literature essays, because this essay got an 8. Upon further reflection, though the essay’s organization appeared to be a bit too structured and uncreative, it did clearly define the specific values that the country supplied the novel’s main character, and thus addresses the question far more than either of the other essays managed to. It also presents ample evidence to support its claims, and though the writing is not stellar to my overly-critical eyes, the author obviously kept the prompt in mind for the duration of the essay, which contributed to the high score received.

Essay 2-
This essay is far too short and wordy to have gotten enough points across to get too many points. That is to say, though sometimes length does not sacrifice content, it did in this case. The author also focused too much on the aspect of humor within The Importance of Being Earnest as opposed to staying true to the question of country values within the play. The essay closes with the author restating its position, saying that The Importance of Being Earnest is “a play of trivial humor” which is not entirely relevant to the question. Though the author does relate the countryside to the play’s comedy, the connection lacks enough evidence to back up the claims made. The question of the prompt was pertaining to specific values associated with the “country” as a whole, not just how the setting served as a plot device to move the story along. The author also makes several grammar and diction mistakes, an example of which being the misuse of the word “discriminate” when what was meant to be said was most likely “distinguish.”

Essay 3-
            The final essay distinctly lacks a scholarly tone and syntax and instead writes as if in conversation, distracting the reader from the point of the essay. Sentences are fragmented and many of the claims made are not described fully in order to relate back to the country setting of Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying. The writing as a whole does not have much complexity. Many of the sentences start with the same words, and their structures do not vary. In trying to get the point across that the South is responsible for many of the character actions within the novel, the author fails to explain how and why such values exist in the “countryside” there. This distinctly misses the point of the question and thus renders the essay a critique on the novel’s characters based on their being from the Southern part of the U.S. Though the evidence from the text is strong for the author’s claims on the qualities of the characters, the fact that it does not relate these qualities strongly enough to the country itself and to the values that are thus present there gave it a rather low score.

3 comments:

  1. Bella,
    I truly enjoyed reading your thoughts about each of the essays. I found it interesting that you didn't come to the same conclusions as the graders of the essay. That does show how you analyzed the essay for what you actually thought instead of just looking at what the grader said and simply agreeing with them, which a lot of us would do. So great job forming your own opinions! With that being said maybe you were a little too harsh on the writer. As we have learned writing these essays can be difficult--especially when you are timed! Like I mentioned before great job creating your own thoughts and actually taking the time to analyze each of the three essays! Next time maybe you could use some more evidence or quotes from the essays themselves as well. Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bella,
    Overall, you did a fine job with your analyses of these essays, but I do have a few points of contention with you. I think you criticism of the first essayist's writing style was a bit unwarranted; I read the essay, and I think its only glaring problems were a few poor diction choices and some redundancy. It was predictable in structure, but so is pretty much every single AP essay. I just feel like it's not as important to be "enjoyable" in one's essay, that getting the information across in a competent, readable manner is the focus. Otherwise, I would include more specific examples directly from the text that support your criticisms.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella,
    Good job analyzing these three essays. It was interesting to read your opinions and compare them with my own, as well as the opinions of the AP board. I’m right there with you; I often find myself disagreeing with the scores the AP board has given. Maybe we’re looking at the essays to critically, or at least differently than the AP readers. I thought your analysis of the first one was pretty fair, although I agree with Drew that I only really saw a few diction errors and redundancy. With your other analysis of the second essay, I agree that this essay strayed from the question some and needed more evidence to support its claims. In regards to the third essay, I agree that the essay was not well written by any means. Great post and great analyses.

    ReplyDelete