Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt #3

In Kate Chopin’s The Awakening (1899), protagonist Edna Pontellier is said to possess “That outward existence which conforms, the inward life that questions.” In a novel or play that you have studied, identify a character who outwardly conforms while questioning inwardly. Then write an essay in which you analyze how this tension between outward conformity and inward questioning contributes to the meaning of the work. Avoid mere plot summary.

In Edward Albee's The American Dream, Grandma acts outwardly as a senile old woman whom the characters readily dismiss, but inwardly she is rather sage and appears to know much more about the world than anyone else in the play. The dichotomy created here contributes to the meaning of the play as a whole by accurately mirroring society's problem of ignoring those possessing wisdom and respectable values in order to promote those of materialism and superficiality; because of this, in order to get anything done, Grandma must act differently than she feels. 
Grandma's outward treatment of the boxes shows us that she can be successful in both fooling those around her into thinking that she is a normal member of their society while ensuring that her secret, inner values will be preserved as she takes them with her when she leaves. Her conforming to her family's view of her as a crazy old lady while clearly understanding more about her world than she lets on hints at the meaning of the work itself. When Grandma is ultimately shoved off to make room for the new American dream, the ultimate point of the play is exposed; those with contradictory values to that of the majority ultimately have no place in society. 
At one point in the play, Grandma recounts the story of when she entered a baking competition with a store-bought cake and won the grand prize. Her knowledge that the store bought cake would win the competition--a direct reflection of society's upholding of materialist, disingenuous things--shows that she conforms outwardly to expectations set upon her, she knows full well the nature of those expectations and how to play them successfully. This contributes to the play's overall meaning in that it both exposes a societal flaw while highlighting Grandma's inner understanding of her surroundings and her ability to interact successfully with a world that she outwardly conforms to while inwardly sees through entirely. 
When speaking to the Young Man, Grandma acts with precision, knowing full well that he would be her replacement in the family and orchestrating that this would be the case. She listens to his dark story involving his long lost twin, and all the while makes non-committal comments regarding his attractiveness and other meaningless features that would be the focus of any other character when interacting with him. At the end of their conversation, however, she whispers her plan into his ear and he obeys, thus ensuring that her vision of the future for her family is fulfilled. Grandma's expression of her society's emphasis on appearance and beauty and inner concoction of the perfect plan do well to show us the nature of her understanding of the difference between how she thinks and how she must act. 
In The American Dream, Grandma understands that if she is to fit into the world around her, the way she acts outwardly must not reflect the thoughts she possesses inwardly. In this, she emphasizes the true meaning of the work; that those who understand the values of their societies, however flawed, and act accordingly regardless of their true feelings. 

1 comment:

  1. Bella,
    "The American Dream" was a good work-choice for this prompt, one I probably would not have jumped to if I were writing on this prompt. But, I honestly feel that this essay is a bit light-weight. Yes, it makes sense, but I didn't really see all that much depth present, and I didn't really understand how you tied what you wrote about Grandma back to the meaning of the play. However, the fact that this type of essay earns a half-way decent mark on the AP essay shows that they have power in the bureaucracy of AP testing, and that if push comes to shove and we have no other choice but to write something shallow, then write it we must.

    ReplyDelete