Tragic Figures as Instruments for the Suffering of Others
In Arthur Miller's mid-20th century play Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman serves as a classic example of the tragic figure in literature. Through his relationship with himself, his family, and with the rest of society, Willy's suffering directly exemplifies that of those he is connected to.
Willy lived a unglamorous life; he worked the majority of the time, produced two dysfunctional children, and in his old age scarcely had enough money to keep his family afloat. Because of this, toward the end of his life he constantly grappled with the thought of suicide, seeing the option as not only as a way out of his predicament but as a way to save his family-- the insurance money collected upon his death would be plenty to keep them living comfortably. Ultimately for these reasons, Willy does commit suicide, hoping that in its aftermath his beloved youngest son Biff will finally start a business and make something of his life; but this is not the case. Willy dies in vain because none of the things he hoped for his family in death actually occur. In this, we see true tragedy, a misguided martyr giving up his life for those who do not truly deserve it.
The Loman family is one of resentment and useless hope that in the end ensures that no two people have a healthy relationship. Willy is completely in love with his son Biff and believes that he is truly capable of greatness, but Biff does not at all share this opinion of himself. Upon catching his father having an affair with a woman when he was just out of high school, Biff loses all respect for Willy and from that point on in life stops seeing himself as worth just about anything. Willy's other son, Happy, is useless in the true sense of the word; he has little real ambition and looks at life with an empty contentment. He is certainly not full of outward and inwardly directed rage like his brother, but his life is just as much of a waste. These broken relationships, born much out of Willy's halfhearted presence in life and thus in the raising of his children are examples of how Willy's actions in life led to the suffering of those he loved most; the tragedy is found in that no matter how hard he tried, he could not fix his sons or make their lives better for them.
The life of struggle Willy led with his insufficient job and low quality of happiness derived from his life in general stands to represent what many fear in life and what much of society is plagued with; sometimes working hard isn't enough, and people are stuck working miserable jobs that hardly pay enough to keep them alive and well. The people Willy expects to help him out offer no assistance, and he rejects it from those who do because he is too busy being unable to comprehend why people he had faith in consistently let him down. In many ways, the story of Death of a Salesman is one of the small but profound fears the majority of society fears for itself; disintegration of family ties, financial instability, and loss of happiness. Willy's suffering represents that of many others, and his tragic life is full of parts that many can relate to.
Willy Loman is a true tragic figure; his life is one of despair and sadness, and he leaves behind a legacy of nothing more than a broken family and some insurance money, despite all of the high hopes of being remembered as a well loved man who did good things in his life. In his downfall, we see elements of suffering that characterize many parts of humanity and a story of a family that could certainly exist in the real world.
Bella,
ReplyDeleteFirst off, this essay/response was super easy to read because it was so organized and concise, so good job on that! I think you picked a perfect example, for a prompt that seems a smidge harder than the others. Although, it was a little difficult to evaluate your response because I wasn't exactly sure what the prompt was asking. Next time you should copy and paste the prompt/year!:) That would be really helpful! From what I can see though, you did a really nice job. You made some strong claims supported by great evidence, including the fact that Biff's unhappiness was derived from Willy's affair. The only thing else I can think to add is to explain a bit more about how your evidence backs up your claim. Although it makes sense to me, since I've read the book, it might not be completely clear to other readers/graders. (I hope they all have read the book though!) Overall, nice work.
Hi Bella,
ReplyDeleteGreat response/essay! Willy and Death of a Salesman fit well for the prompt. You had a good intro and thesis statement. Next it would be helpful if you included the whole prompt because I wasn’t one hundred percent sure what I was looking for when I was reading your essay. You do a good job of using evidence from the play to support your claims such as how he views the insurance money/death as a way to success. I think it would make your essay stronger though if you expanded a bit more on how Willy causes suffering in his own family, you do a great job though on explain/analyzing Willy specifically. Overall great job Bell, especially because this is really our first open prompt.
Bella,
ReplyDeleteWhat a coincidence, I did the same play for the same prompt; we both used Willy Loman as our tragic figure. Having done the same thing for my post, I think I was a bit biased as to how I wanted your essay to go, but this was a great essay. It had great flow throughout and your arguments were strongly supported with good evidence. I really only have two minor things I would change. First, I would have liked to see the prompt, just to make sure you were answering the question (not that I doubt you did, I know you did). Second, I wish you had explained what makes a tragic hero the tragic hero (the fall, the fatal flaw, etc.). Reading back through your essay, I think it’s interesting that you called Willy Loman a “classic example of the tragic figure” because many critics argue that he doesn’t fit the qualifications of one. Just a little food for thought, but amazing job Bella.