Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt Response 3

Prompt:  Comment on the function of a foil in a piece of literature of your choice.

Essay #1- As has become typical for me upon reading these first essays, I found the student’s description of the foils present in Amy Tan’s Joy Luck Club to be lackluster at best. The language did not flow very well, and the syntax of the overall piece was stiff. It appeared to me that rather than focus on the specific character traits that supported his or her claim that the two characters at hand were indeed foils, the author instead more or less gave an entire synopsis of the novel in a three-page essay. This essay of course got an 8, though, so the graders had to have seen something of value in the writer’s tactic. I would say that perhaps the large amount of textual evidence, sufficient foil-like connections between the two characters, and author’s prudent series of restatements of the prompt throughout the essay all contributed to it not being truly terrible. Personally, I would give it more of a 6 for lack of clarity and truly well-developed ideas, but alas, I am not a well-trained AP grader, so my opinion is not a valid one.

Essay #2- Not entirely developed and lacking in coherent structure, this student’s essay knew what it wanted to say, just not quite how to say it. Full of grammar errors and fragmented sentences, the flow of the essay was off, making it difficult to decipher who exactly the student thought Celie’s foil to be: her father or ‘Shug.’ While there was much textual evidence present to support the claims the author made, it simply made too many. This lack of coherency lead to a less valuable essay overall and is what I would think led to its lower score of a 6. Though the author surely knew the meaning of a foil—it even introduced the concept of Maslow’s hierarchy—the details it provided in attempt to support its claims about the character’s path to self-actualization were too spread-out and did not make obvious statements as to which character served as Celie’s foil. It seemed in the beginning that Celie’s father was her foil, and in the middle it appeared that it was instead Shug that taught Celie her important values. But in the end, the author restated that it was indeed her father, a thought process very confusing to the reader.

Essay #3- Beginning with an intro that could have come from a mind with the scholarly intellect of a six year old, the third essay was unpromising from the start. It neglected to produce a well-formed thesis in the start of the essay, which made the rest of the essay seem jumbled and random, as there was no real claim to relate it back to. It was also less than 1 ½ pages, a hilariously short amount of space in which to get a whole AP essay. The concept of a foil was not clear in the essay, which suggests that the author itself might not have truly known the definition of the term in the first place. Other than claiming that Baba highlighted Hassans good qualities, none of the claims the author made really seemed to answer the prompt in the way that was expected. As the AP grade said, the style of the essay was overly “simplistic”, which is why it received a measly 4/9. I guess the graders were feeling generous that grading day.



3 comments:

  1. Bella,
    Engaging analysis of the provided student essays. I thought you were sufficient in your study of them and I appreciated your comments in the areas where they either failed or excelled. You take note of the grammatical errors that each student engages in , and your honest voice relays the fact that you aware of how each student can improve. And then there's the first essay, which I thought, was quite intriguing. To know that you didn't agree with the AP Readers...whoa. Way to say it. As to what you could do better? Hmm in the your third paragraph you include a brief quote from the AP Readers, maybe next time fit more quotes in throughout all of your paragraphs to support your claims. You know when you mention the areas where a student could have put in a bit more effort. Allow your readers to see too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Bella,

    Nice job on your responses to the student essays. That is so interesting that you did not agree with the AP readers! I guess that shows that you are actually reading them and coming to your own conclusions instead of just saying the same things that the AP readers said. I really liked the way you wrote these responses too. I can tell that it is your own voice and it is entertaining to read. You definitely did not go easy on these writers though and gave your honest opinion:) Which is good...sometimes I am too easy on the writers since I know how hard it can be to write these. The only thing that you could add to make it better is direct quotes from the essays themselves. You say a lot of great things but you do not have the text to back up your claims. Overall, well done on this blog!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bella, I don't have much else to add after Ludia and Katie's comments. I thought your analysis of these student essays was exceptional, not too mention brutally honest. (Don't worry I agree with the points you made.) I liked how you referenced the AP reader and their grading. It was interesting too see your disagreement with them, but that's okay, at least your being honest. The only thing I could say is perhaps provide some more textual evidence as the other two editors have pointed out! Well, that's all I can think of!

    ReplyDelete