Sunday, September 15, 2013

He's Not Holden- An Analysis of Rosenbaum's Style

In Slate article He’s Not Holden (link below), author Ron Rosenbaum laments the tendency of people to attribute the thoughts and ideas of characters to the authors that created them. In his work, Rosenbaum goes in-depth about this issue, citing the recent film and book Salinger to make his case. Rosenbaum use of dynamic language, quality syntax, and varying diction allows him to get his point across in a fashion that makes his article easily comprehensible yet well-informed.
The language in which Rosenbaum writes his article is one that conveys both his expansive knowledge on the subject of Salinger and his keen sense of humor. It makes the reading both easy to comprehend and also to respect, as it is apparent that Rosenbaum is a very educated man. Parts of the piece are written quite informally, as if they are to be spoken to a friend or colleague. When Rosenbaum writes “Aha, the authors virtually high five each other: proof!” the effect of this conversational language on the reader is positive in that it lends a bit of excitement to the informative piece. Rosenbaum’s opener, “I didn’t want to write this piece. I’ve got Salinger fatigue, and I bet you do too” (Rosenbaum) for example, is quite a personable start for a piece that is supposed to be educational, but the author’s use of this technique allows the reader to become more engaged an interested with the work.
Rosenbaum’s use of syntax allows his work to be read quite easily, even enjoyably, and makes no room for possible comprehension errors. He is careful not to make his work seem dry or stuffy; everything about the structure of the article is fast-paced and interesting. No two sentences follow the exact same pattern, which ensures that those reading the piece will remain interested. Much of the syntax reads like a conversation, or at the very least an informal commentary. For example, Rosenbaum’s phrase “And a great relief! It almost sounds as if Salinger found a way to escape the Glass family trap (the trapped family Glass?) by writing explicitly about his wartime experiences” (Rosenbaum) uses very dynamic and unusual punctuation, such as exclamation points and parentheses. This makes the reading much more appealing to the human eye and mind, thus holding an observer’s intrigue.  

He’s Not Holden’s diction is quite scholarly in that very uncommon and high-brow words are used fairly often. Though the article itself is perfectly simple to understand, it is entirely possible for a reader to get caught up on a word or two. Rosenbaum is undeniably an educated, scholarly man; he chooses to use words such as “perpetuates”, “fundamental”, and “recrudescence”, all of which have much simpler synonyms. This allows the article to sound much more intellectual in reading. A good portion of his phrases, such as “[he] stuffed his later prose with undigested mystical didactism” (Rosenbaum) use this elevated diction as well. The article is altogether extremely informed and lively in its nature and in the way it is perceived by a reader. 

A link to the original article-
http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/the_spectator/2013/09/interpreting_catcher_in_the_rye_the_one_big_mistake_people_make.html

3 comments:

  1. After reading the article myself, I do agree with you when you say that Rosenbaum's: "use of dynamic language, quality syntax, and varying diction allows him to get his point across as a fashion that makes his article easily comprehensible yet well informed." Perhaps this is because his voice shoots through the information-giving endeavor, and we feel more like he's just telling us how he feels as if in person. He is educated yes, but I don't know that the word "scholarly" is necessary though because when it follows "Rosenbaum is undeniably an educated,..." it sounds a bit repetitive. Although you're getting your point across, it feels almost pompous. My only other advice is to take out the first "and" in the last sentence because although conjunctions are needed when linking together separate clauses in a well formed sentence, taking out the "and" before "lively" and just adding a comma would suit the closing statement more effectively.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think all of these points are excellent and hit the nail right on the head. I don't think I'd agree with this (^^^) one about the removal of that particular conjunction, but I'd suggest avoiding unnecessary passive voice in the beginning of the last paragraph, as well as refraining from overusing phrases linked with "in that". All the points listed are well backed and I feel I had no trouble understanding anything. Getting really picky here: when "language" is used to open the first paragraph, you're using it as a mass noun (e.g. spinach) but used "one" later on, which conveys a language (e.g. English, French, etc.), not a literary technique category. This was really easy to read and mostly flowed without trouble, but, I feel, the sentence length could be a bit more varied; at times, the flow gets a little choppy, particularly in the third paragraph. All in all, you've got the content, but the rhythm could use a little work.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love that you chose this article, Bella-- you know this "author does not equal narrator" issue is one of my pet peeves!

    ReplyDelete