Student #1's essay does an overall adequate job at analyzing the excerpt given, but has a fairly week opening sentence. It begins with the discussion of Desai's use of a "variety of techiniques", a statement that could well have been better dictated. The thesis of the essay, however, is clear and easy to follow as it foreshadows the essay's specific topics including "alternating diction, speech, and point of view". The essay falters a bit on its use of descriptive words and phrases. For example, rather than referring to the diction as "matter-of-fact type", the student would have done well to choose a more concise adjective. As the essay wears on, it is obvious that the student understands what the question is asking and consistently makes good connections between the text and the the author's intent. The student's use of quotes to support the essay's positions is ample, but doesn't distract from the voice of the student itself. It is quite apparent that the student is well-versed in the devices used in literature as it describes the use of third person limited/omniscient narrative and rhetorical questions within the text. From here the students makes an observation of the use of irony in the passage to create an unsettled mood for the main character as he interacts with his new surroundings. The closing paragraph effectively restates the point of the essay and serves as a good closure for the work itself.
Student #2's essay begins nicely with a
detailed topic sentence that sets the tone and message of the essay. Some of
the word choice reflects the student's desire to sound overly intelligent. The
use of words such as "fostered", "heightened", and
"apprehensive" make the voice of the essay sound bulky and
overstated, especially when such words have much simpler synonyms that would be
a better fit to the text. It appears that the first paragraph lacks a concrete
thesis statement. The student obviously has good ideas regarding the literary
devices used in the excerpt but continues to overdo the descriptions used in
the defense of its ideas. Many of the sentences begin with the word
"He" or "The", and the lack of variation creates a dull
tone that is not entirely engaging. Aside from some of the mechanical and tonal issues, the essay itself makes accurate connections to the excerpt given and properly addresses all parts of the prompt. The lack of conclusion at the
end of the essay causes it to end rather abruptly without a final restatement
of ideas and surely caused graders to take off a few points from its grade.
Student #3's essay uses overly simple language and diction that makes the point of the essay vague and difficult to fully understand from the very beginning. The majority of the sentences begin with "The" or "He", both of with are uninteresting openers and must be switched up every once in a while to create a better tone to the essay. Rather than defending an opinion on the literary devices used in the excerpt with relevant information, it appears that student is simply dictating information to the reader in a fashion that is not engaging. Many of the positions the student takes are obvious from the reading and are in turn not conclusions based on information, but rather restatements of what are likely sections from the excerpt. The student's thoughts appear undeveloped and quite basic in the way they are structured and presented throughout the paragraphs. In addition, the student only discusses two devices of literature, narration and speech, and provides little indication as to which one it is referring to at a given point in the essay. Overall, the work itself was vague and did not come to the proper conclusion that the prompt desired from students.
You do a terrific job with analyzing what it is that you like and don’t like in the novel: Fasting, Feasting by Anita Desai. You use very specific examples in each student’s essay and bring up which element of D.I.L.D.S (diction, imagery, language, detail, and syntax) and S.T.I.F.S (speaker, tone, images, figurative language, and situation) are used and/or underused. The only advice that I can give to you, and I am not entirely sure, is to check and see if you are supposed to analyze each student response essay in its own post. I would just double check a few other peoples blogs to make sure, but don’t quote me. And just because I am curious, I would like to know what you thought of the piece. You have your own unique voice and I myself have not yet read Anita Desai’s Fasting, Feasting. I would find your personal insight valuable.
ReplyDeleteI can confirm that this is supposed to be in three individual posts, so we can fix that next time around. To be honest, your voice in this entry reminds me of Dr. Brennan from Bones during an autopsy when she is speaking into a recorder. The running commentary "sounds" very direct, almost scientific, as you dissected each response. Refreshing voice aside, I find your process of going through these essays very easy to follow with the quasi-informal syntax and diction. After hearing your response to the essays, I, too, am interested in hearing what you would have to say about the passage in a less formal context than a full-blown essay; I understand no one has much free time these days.
ReplyDelete